Results compiled by Ken Stewart
Season 1999 Spens Cup 1998-99
1 InverclydeC 2 Paisley
2120 MacDonald Kevin 0 - 1 Umesh Santosh 2110
1875 Moffat Leonie 1 - 0 Cochrane Richard 1980
1850 Hilton Steve H 0 - 1 Matheis Thomas 1905
1710 Doherty Stephen 0 - 1 Kafka Graeme 1730
1615 MacGranaghan James 0 - 1 Roy Michael 1705
1325 Logue David 0 - 1 MacFarlane Alex H 1680
1 - 5
4 CivilService 5 Holy Cross
1815 Greensmith David ½ - ½ Stalker Adrian G 1855
1780 Austin Rudolf J 1 - 0 Lonie David 1690
1775 Melville Alan G 1 - 0 Tweedie Steven 1345
1760 Prince Alan R 1 - 0 Shepka Bryan 1280
1610 Jackson Ralph 1 - 0 Tweedie Christopher 1250
1585 Heatlie Douglas S 1 - 0 Pollock Murray 1240
5½ - ½
6 Kilmarnock 7 Peterhead
1885 Malkin Kenneth 0 - 1 Neil Kenneth D 2170
1865 Hamilton Douglas 1 - 0 Pert Kevin 1540
1825 Kleboe James P R ½ - ½ Murison Jim 1480
1745 Docherty James 1 - 0 Watson Jim 1430
1650 Armour James W 1 - 0 Nicol Mark M 1315
1505 MacNicoll John D 0 - 1 Rose Anthony 0
3½ - 2½
8 Bellshill 9 Kilwinning
1910 Nichols Robert ½ - ½ MacGovern Patrick 1845
1520 Kane Alan 0 - 1 King Graeme E 1780
1440 Carnie Wilson 0 - 1 Walsh Philip F 1775
1315 Fife Robert 0 - 1 Loughran Robert 1600
1310 Cumming James ½ - ½ Harkins George 1500
1055 Docherty Andrew ½ - ½ Gourlay Robert 1425
1½ - 4½
10 IsleofLewis 11 Dunfermline
1870 Macleod Mike J ½ - ½ Robertson Ian C 2095
1650 Wallace Calum Ross ½ - ½ O'Neil Jim 1790
1350 Gatensby Jim 0 - 1 Ossowski Francis G 1705
1005 MacAulay Iain 0 - 1 Forbes Andrew W 1730
910 Macleod Donald S 0 - 1 Brisbane W Stewart 1680
890 Rankin Joe 0 - 1 Grant Glynis 1285
1 - 5
13 GlasMontrose 12 Stirling
2175 Montgomery Jim 1 - 0 Smith Stephen H 1815
2090 Beaton Ken S 1 - 0 Cowie Iain 1730
2075 Yuill David A 1 - 0 Hayles Robin W 1655
1885 Collins Sam 1 - 0 Hunter William 1610
1745 MacCaffrey Kenny 1 - 0 Thomson Alex D C 1590
1515 Perdikou Evis 0 - 1 Togneri Robert G 1530
5 - 1
14 Dumfries 15 Perth
1820 Brown David E 0 - 1 Hall David G 1805
1645 Cunningham Stephen 1 - 0 Roth Michael J 1780
1635 MacIlhinney Eric ½ - ½ Galloway John 0
1480 Maxwell Les 0 - 1 Roberts Martin P 1670
1435 Thomson Colin 0 - 1 Warren John 1600
1410 Sim Robert C 0 - 1 Harvey Douglas 1460
1½ - 4½
2 Paisley 3 Phones
2110 Umesh Santosh ½ - ½ Dickson Robert 1980
1980 Cochrane Richard ½ - ½ Macdonald Stewart 1980
1730 Kafka Graeme ½ - ½ Wiltshire Richard 2000
1705 Roy Michael 0 - 1 Strathern Kevin M 1865
1585 Rooney Michael (Snr) 0 - 1 MacIntyre John W 1845
1065 Thornton Jim 0 - 1 Carlin Joe 1810
1½ - 4½
6 Kilmarnock 4 CivilService
1885 Malkin Kenneth 0 - 1 Austin Rudolf J 1780
1865 Hamilton Douglas 1 - 0 Melville Alan G 1775
1825 Kleboe James P R 1 - 0 Jackson Ralph 1610
1805 Parks Joe 1 - 0 Bate Simon 1550
1745 Docherty James 0 - 1 Heatlie Douglas S 1585
1650 Armour James W 1 - 0 Anderson George C 1500
4 - 2
9 Kilwinning 11 Dunfermline
1890 Barrett Tommy 0 - 1 Robertson Ian C 2095
1845 MacGovern Patrick ½ - ½ O'Neil Jim 1790
1780 King Graeme E 1 - 0 Ossowski Francis G 1705
1775 Walsh Philip F 0 - 1 Brisbane W Stewart 1680
1655 Shankland John 0 - 1 MacArthur John M 1595
1600 Loughran Robert 1 - 0 Horne Peter 1255
2½ - 3½
13 GlasMontrose 15 Perth
2175 Montgomery Jim 1 - 0 Gourlay Martin 1820
2075 Yuill David A 1 - 0 Hall David G 1805
2090 Beaton Ken S 1 - 0 Roth Michael J 1780
1885 Collins Sam 0 - 1 Hall Adam W 1700
1745 MacCaffrey Kenny 1 - 0 Roberts Martin P 1670
1515 Perdikou Evis 0 - 1 Galloway John 0
4 - 2
3 Phones 6 Kilmarnock
2000 Wiltshire Richard ½ - ½ Hamilton Douglas 1865
1980 Dickson Robert ½ - ½ Malkin Kenneth 1885
1980 Macdonald Stewart ½ - ½ Parks Joe 1805
1955 Brady Stuart ½ - ½ Kleboe James P R 1825
1865 Strathern Kevin M ½ - ½ Docherty James 1745
1810 Carlin Joe 1 - 0 Armour James W 1650
3½ - 2½
11 Dunfermline 13 GlasMontrose
2095 Robertson Ian C 0 - 1 Montgomery Jim 2175
1790 O'Neil Jim 0 - 1 Yuill David A 2075
1730 Forbes Andrew W 1 - 0 Collins Sam 1885
1705 Ossowski Francis G 0 - 1 MacCaffrey Kenny 1745
1680 Brisbane W Stewart ½ - ½ Reid David 1635
Not Given - Not Given Not Played
1½ - 3½
12 Stirling 8 Bellshill
1815 Smith Stephen H 0 - 1 Nichols Robert 1910
1760 Pitson Anthony E 1 - 0 Carnie Wilson 1440
1730 Cowie Iain 0 - 1 Fife Robert 1315
1655 Hayles Robin W 0 - 1 Cumming James 1310
1620 Hewitt David A 1 - 0 Campbell Kevin 1060
1610 Hunter William 1 - 0 Docherty Andrew 1055
3 - 3
10 IsleofLewis 7 Peterhead
1870 Macleod Mike J ½ - ½ Neil Kenneth D 2170
1710 Murray Roderick M 0 - 1 Pert Kevin 1540
1205 Millar Andrew 0 - 1 Murison Jim 1480
1005 MacAulay Iain 0 - 1 Watson Jim 1430
910 Macleod Donald S 0 - 1 Rose Anthony 0
565 Bell Daniel 0 - 1 Bruce Jim 1190
½ - 5½
7 Peterhead 1 InverclydeC
2170 Neil Kenneth D 1 - 0 MacDonald Kevin 2120
1540 Pert Kevin 0 - 1 Hilton Steve H 1850
0 Rose Anthony 0 - 1 Doherty Stephen 1710
1480 Murison Jim 0 - 1 MacGranaghan James 1615
1315 Nicol Mark M ½ - ½ Logue David 1325
Not Given - Not Given Not Played
1½ - 3½
8 Bellshill 14 Dumfries
1910 Nichols Robert 1 - 0 Brown David E 1820
1520 Kane Alan 0 - 1 Cunningham Stephen 1645
1440 Carnie Wilson 0 - 1 Carruthers John 1530
1315 Fife Robert 0 - 1 Maxwell Les 1480
1310 Cumming James 0 - 1 Thomson Colin 1435
1060 Campbell Kevin 0 - 1 Sim Robert C 1410
1 - 5
13 GlasMontrose 3 Phones
2075 Yuill David A 0 - 1 Wiltshire Richard 2000
2090 Beaton Ken S 1 - 0 Dickson Robert 1980
1885 Collins Sam 0 - 1 Macdonald Stewart 1980
1745 MacCaffrey Kenny 0 - 1 Brady Stuart 1955
1635 Reid David 1 - 0 Strathern Kevin M 1865
1605 Dempsey John ½ - ½ MacIntyre John W 1845
2½ - 3½
14 Dumfries 1 InverclydeC
1820 Brown David E ½ - ½ MacDonald Kevin 2120
1530 Carruthers John 0 - 1 Hilton Steve H 1850
1480 Maxwell Les ½ - ½ Doherty Stephen 1710
1435 Thomson Colin 1 - 0 MacGranaghan James 1615
1365 Marchbank Stuart ½ - ½ Smith Andy 1415
0 Brack William ½ - ½ Logue David 1325
3 - 3
Table Order = M pts
----------Boards (6 per Match)--------
----Matches---- ---Played--- --Defaults-- -Score-
Pos Team P W L D Pts W L D W L D Bds %
1 3 Phones 3 3 0 0 6 7 2 9 0 0 0 11½ 64
2 13 GlasMontrose 4 3 1 0 6 14 7 2 0 1 0 15 63
3 11 Dunfermline 3 2 1 0 4 8 5 4 0 1 0 10 56
4 6 Kilmarnock 3 2 1 0 4 7 5 6 0 0 0 10 56
5 14 Dumfries 3 1 1 1 3 7 6 5 0 0 0 9½ 53
6 1 InverclydeC 3 1 1 1 3 5 7 5 0 1 0 7½ 42
7 4 CivilService 2 1 1 0 2 7 4 1 0 0 0 7½ 63
8 9 Kilwinning 2 1 1 0 2 5 3 4 0 0 0 7 58
9 2 Paisley 2 1 1 0 2 5 4 3 0 0 0 6½ 54
10 15 Perth 2 1 1 0 2 6 5 1 0 0 0 6½ 54
11 7 Peterhead 3 1 2 0 2 8 6 3 0 1 0 9½ 53
12 12 Stirling 2 0 1 1 1 4 8 0 0 0 0 4 33
13 8 Bellshill 3 0 2 1 1 4 11 3 0 0 0 5½ 31
14 10 IsleofLewis 2 0 2 0 0 0 9 3 0 0 0 1½ 13
15 5 Holy Cross 1 0 1 0 0 0 5 1 0 0 0 ½ 8
-- -- -- -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ----
Tots for x-check 38 17 17 4 38 87 87 50 0 4 0 112
Match Cross Table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Pld Pts
1 InverclydeC x 1 3½ 3 18 7½
2 Paisley 5 x 1½ 12 6½
3 Phones 4½ x 3½ 3½ 18 11½
4 CivilService x 5½ 2 12 7½
5 Holy Cross ½ x 6 ½
6 Kilmarnock 2½ 4 x 3½ 18 10
7 Peterhead 1½ 2½ x 5½ 18 9½
8 Bellshill x 1½ 3 1 18 5½
9 Kilwinning 4½ x 2½ 12 7
10 IsleofLewis ½ x 1 12 1½
11 Dunfermline 3½ 5 x 1½ 18 10
12 Stirling 3 x 1 12 4
13 GlasMontrose 2½ 3½ 5 x 4 24 15
14 Dumfries 3 5 x 1½ 18 9½
15 Perth 2 4½ x 12 6½
*** Team 1 InverclydeC ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5016 MacDonald Kevin 2120 IC 3 ½
5313 Moffat Leonie 1875 PYIC 1 1
4357 Hilton Steve H 1850 ICPW 3 2
3754 Doherty Stephen 1710 ICPG 3 1½
5073 MacGranaghan James 1615 IC 3 1
9493 Logue David 1325 J16 IC 3 1
6016 Smith Andy 1415 IC 1 ½
*** Team 2 Paisley ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6315 Umesh Santosh 2110 PA 2 1½
3543 Cochrane Richard 1980 PACW 2 ½
4892 Matheis Thomas 1905 PA 1 1
4517 Kafka Graeme 1730 J16 LGPA 2 1½
7867 Roy Michael 1705 J20 PA 2 1
5036 MacFarlane Alex H 1680 PA 1 1
11986 Rooney Michael (Snr) 1585 PACW 1 0
6260 Thornton Jim 1065 PACW 1 0
*** Team 3 Phones ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3731 Dickson Robert 1980 KRPO 3 1
4818 Macdonald Stewart 1980 POBA 3 2
6517 Wiltshire Richard 2000 PO 3 2
6645 Strathern Kevin M 1865 KRPO 3 1½
5102 MacIntyre John W 1845 PO 2 1½
3440 Carlin Joe 1810 PO 2 2
3264 Brady Stuart 1955 PO 2 1½
*** Team 4 CivilService ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
7914 Greensmith David 1815 CS 1 ½
3084 Austin Rudolf J 1780 EDCS 2 2
9060 Melville Alan G 1775 CSWD 2 1
10488 Prince Alan R 1760 CS 1 1
11978 Jackson Ralph 1610 CS 2 1
4313 Heatlie Douglas S 1585 CSWD 2 2
3143 Bate Simon 1550 CS 1 0
3046 Anderson George C 1500 CS 1 0
*** Team 5 Holy Cross ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6081 Stalker Adrian G 1855 HC 1 ½
4720 Lonie David 1690 HC 1 0
9123 Tweedie Steven 1345 J11 AJHC 1 0
9116 Shepka Bryan 1280 J14 HC 1 0
9122 Tweedie Christopher 1250 J15 AJHC 1 0
8339 Pollock Murray 1240 J13 AJHC 1 0
*** Team 6 Kilmarnock ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
7619 Malkin Kenneth 1885 KM 3 ½
4236 Hamilton Douglas 1865 KM 3 2½
4611 Kleboe James P R 1825 KM 3 2
3744 Docherty James 1745 KM 3 1½
3073 Armour James W 1650 KM 3 2
5209 MacNicoll John D 1505 KM 1 0
5575 Parks Joe 1805 KM 2 1½
*** Team 7 Peterhead ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5465 Neil Kenneth D 2170 PT 3 2½
7842 Pert Kevin 1540 PT 3 1
5422 Murison Jim 1480 PT 3 1½
6400 Watson Jim 1430 PT 2 1
6681 Nicol Mark M 1315 NMPT 2 ½
13631 Rose Anthony 0 PT 3 2
10794 Bruce Jim 1190 PT 1 1
*** Team 8 Bellshill ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5482 Nichols Robert 1910 BH 3 2½
4518 Kane Alan 1520 BH 2 0
3447 Carnie Wilson 1440 BH 3 0
7037 Fife Robert 1315 BH 3 1
3656 Cumming James 1310 BH 3 1½
10071 Docherty Andrew 1055 J11 BHSG 2 ½
12370 Campbell Kevin 1060 J15 HCBH 2 0
*** Team 9 Kilwinning ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5063 MacGovern Patrick 1845 ARKW 2 1
4597 King Graeme E 1780 KW 2 2
6369 Walsh Philip F 1775 KW 2 1
4725 Loughran Robert 1600 KW 2 2
4263 Harkins George 1500 KW 1 ½
7499 Gourlay Robert 1425 KIKW 1 ½
3137 Barrett Tommy 1890 KW 1 0
5949 Shankland John 1655 KW 1 0
*** Team 10 IsleofLewis ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4827 Macleod Mike J 1870 LX 2 1
6345 Wallace Calum Ross 1650 LX 1 ½
9453 Gatensby Jim 1350 LX 1 0
13025 MacAulay Iain 1005 NEW LX 2 0
5172 Macleod Donald S 910 LX 2 0
12781 Rankin Joe 890 J10 ALLX 1 0
9465 Murray Roderick M 1710 LX 1 0
9460 Millar Andrew 1205 LX 1 0
12515 Bell Daniel 565 J10 ALLX 1 0
*** Team 11 Dunfermline ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5811 Robertson Ian C 2095 DLWD 3 1½
5536 O'Neil Jim 1790 DLWD 3 1
5557 Ossowski Francis G 1705 DL 3 1
3956 Forbes Andrew W 1730 DL 2 2
3281 Brisbane W Stewart 1680 DLCN 3 2½
4166 Grant Glynis 1285 DL 1 1
4749 MacArthur John M 1595 DL 1 1
9311 Horne Peter 1255 DL 1 0
*** Team 12 Stirling ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6052 Smith Stephen H 1815 STCW 2 0
3616 Cowie Iain 1730 ST 2 0
4307 Hayles Robin W 1655 KRST 2 0
12220 Hunter William 1610 ST 2 1
6236 Thomson Alex D C 1590 ST 1 0
6276 Togneri Robert G 1530 ST 1 1
5644 Pitson Anthony E 1760 STDB 1 1
8570 Hewitt David A 1620 ST 1 1
*** Team 13 GlasMontrose ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5329 Montgomery Jim 2175 GMIC 3 3
3157 Beaton Ken S 2090 GM 3 3
6574 Yuill David A 2075 GM 4 3
3560 Collins Sam 1885 GMAY 4 1
11327 MacCaffrey Kenny 1745 GM 4 3
11329 Perdikou Evis 1515 GM 2 0
5735 Reid David 1635 GMAY 2 1½
6685 Dempsey John 1605 GM 1 ½
*** Team 14 Dumfries ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
9157 Brown David E 1820 DFKB 3 ½
12222 Cunningham Stephen 1645 DF 2 2
9154 MacIlhinney Eric 1635 DF 1 ½
7551 Maxwell Les 1480 DF 3 1½
7556 Thomson Colin 1435 DF 3 2
7557 Sim Robert C 1410 DF 2 1
7542 Carruthers John 1530 DF 2 1
8398 Marchbank Stuart 1365 DF 1 ½
12301 Brack William 0 DF 1 ½
*** Team 15 Perth ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4230 Hall David G 1805 PR 2 1
9972 Roth Michael J 1780 PRCH 2 0
13262 Galloway John 0 PR 2 1½
5796 Roberts Martin P 1670 PRBG 2 1
6388 Warren John 1600 PRIV 1 1
4288 Harvey Douglas 1460 PRBG 1 1
4146 Gourlay Martin 1820 PRKI 1 0
6653 Hall Adam W 1700 J15 PR 1 1