+- Forums (https://www.chessscotland.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Members Only (https://www.chessscotland.com/forum/forum-16.html)
+--- Forum: Ask the Grader (https://www.chessscotland.com/forum/forum-12.html)
+--- Thread: Stewarton Allegro Open grading - correction (/thread-1260.html)
Stewarton Allegro Open grading - correction - Alan Jelfs - 27-06-2015
Hi Dougie,
There is an error (maybe more) in the grading results of the Stewarton Allegro Open.
In the last round, I drew with Rosie Giulian, not Phil.
Lennart Koehn thinks his result against one of the Giulians is wrong too.
So I reckon Rosie has Phil's results and vice versa !
Boards 5 and 7 shouldn't meet in round 1.
Best regards,
Alan
(posting here since you have disabled PMs)
Re: Stewarton Allegro Open grading - correction - Phil Thomas - 27-06-2015
For Dougie,
I did not keep written records but I recall that my results from Stewarton were
Round 1 Draw vs A.Gillies
Round 2 Loss vs I. Brownlee
Round 3 Draw vs S. Brown
Round 4 Win vs Rosie Giuilian
Round 5 Win vs J. Doyle
The results table incorrectly shows me beating Rosie's husband in round 4.
My memory concurs with the results table for rounds 1,2,3,5
Perhaps results from the 2 Giuilians have been switched throughout
Re: Stewarton Allegro Open grading - correction - Douglas Bryson - 28-06-2015
Thanks - John M has indicated the Giulians should be switched round and that should appear in the revised upload next Wednesday.
Re: Stewarton Allegro Open grading - correction - JohnMontgomerySCC - 02-07-2015
Sorry folks
It's my eyesight that is going - I got two pnums mixed up when entering the grading data - Rosie Giulian is 4094 and Phil Giulian is 4093
So contrary to popular belief it is not the case that I cannot tell the difference between Rosie and Phil - just their pnums.
Douglas is going to sort it out in grading this week
My apologies again
John Montgomery
Stewarton Chess Club