Results compiled by Alan Armstrong
Commentary by Gerry Wilson
Scottish National League Division 1 1997-98 'Final' Position
CW AB KY EW MS CH GR CW P W D L F A - Pt
Crowwood A ** 6 2 4 4½ 5 5½ 5½ 7 6 0 1 32½ 9½ 0 12
Aberdeen 0 ** 2½ 6d 4 4 5½ 6 4 0 2 22 14 0 8
Kirkcaldy 4 3½ ** 2 4 1½ 6 6 4 0 2 21 15 0 8
Edinburgh West 2 0d 4 ** 4½ 0d 3 6 7 3 1 3 19½ 22½ 0 7
Musselburgh 1½ 2 2 1½ ** 5 6 5½ 7 3 0 4 23½ 18½ 0 6
Castlehill 1 6d 1 ** 5 4 2 0 2 13 11 0 4
Grangemouth ½ 2 4½ 3 0 1 ** 0 7 1 1 5 11 31 0 3
Crowwood B ½ ½ 0 0 ½ 6 ** 6 1 0 5 7½ 28½ 0 2
The 1st division of the SNCL has been won yet again by Crowwood A. This
season's results were obscured by the non-appearance of Castlehill and
Aberdeen for rounds 3 and 4 due to weather, and the subsequent best
efforts of the organisers to play as many matches as possible has meant
that it is unclear as to who Castlehill defaulted to in their missing
matches. It is hoped that this will be cleared up.
Season 1998 SNCL Div 1
1 Crowwood "A" 2 Castlehill A
2385 Bryson Douglas M (IM 1 - 0 Clapham Robert E 1975
2230 Norris Alan 0 - 1 Kleppang David L 1910
2030 Nolan Graeme 1 - 0 Mooney Graham 1825
2025 Henderson John B H - A MacNab Ian A 1740 Home Win by Default
1975 Doyle James 1 - 0 Chalmers Paul A 1605
1710 Fisher James R 1 - 0 Chalmers Martin M 1515
5 - 1
3 Musselburgh 4 Crowwood "B"
2165 Weng Annegret 1 - 0 Gillespie Dave L 1750
2145 Paterson Graham ½ - ½ MacConnell Pat 1690
1875 Konarski Jannic 1 - 0 Watson John 1650
1815 Galbraith Joe 1 - 0 MacRae James S 1585
1740 Tate Alan 1 - 0 Pollock Andrew 1430
1660 MacIntosh Alasdair 1 - 0 Haggarty Nat W 1235
5½ - ½
5 Grangemouth 6 Kirkcaldy
2115 Robertson Ian C 1 - 0 Burnett Andrew B 2235
1915 Will Douglas 1 - 0 Pyrich George D 2065
1610 Watson James Philip ½ - ½ Fyfe Graeme S S 2035
1435 Gray B William 0 - 1 Thomson Thomas 1805
1280 Washington Ian 1 - 0 Saxton Gavin 1715
0 Ross James W 1 - 0 Pearson Walter J 1680
4½ - 1½
7 Aberdeen 8 Edin/West
*** H Home Win By Default ***
6 - 0
4 Crowwood "B" 1 Crowwood "A"
1975 Doyle James 0 - 1 Bryson Douglas M (IM 2385
1710 Fisher James R 0 - 1 Norris Alan 2230
1650 Watson John 0 - 1 Nolan Graeme 2030
1585 MacRae James S ½ - ½ Henderson John B 2025
1430 Pollock Andrew 0 - 1 Gillespie Dave L 1750
1235 Haggarty Nat W 0 - 1 MacConnell Pat 1690
½ - 5½
6 Kirkcaldy 3 Musselburgh
2235 Burnett Andrew B 1 - 0 Weng Annegret 2165
2065 Pyrich George D 0 - 1 Paterson Graham 2145
2035 Fyfe Graeme S S 1 - 0 Konarski Jannic 1875
1805 Thomson Thomas ½ - ½ Galbraith Joe 1815
1715 Saxton Gavin ½ - ½ Tate Alan 1740
1680 Pearson Walter J 1 - 0 MacIntosh Alasdair 1660
4 - 2
7 Aberdeen 5 Grangemouth
2120 Berry Neil M ½ - ½ Robertson Ian C 2115
1950 Shepherd Mike 1 - 0 Will Douglas 1915
1910 Cavanagh Mike ½ - ½ Watson James Philip 1610
1825 Coffey Thomas A - H Gray B William 1435 Away Win by Default
1810 Donaghay Michael R 1 - 0 Washington Ian 1280
1775 Clifford John 1 - 0 Ross James W 0
4 - 2
2 Castlehill A 8 Edin/West
*** H Home Win By Default ***
6 - 0
3 Musselburgh 1 Crowwood "A"
1875 Konarski Jannic 0 - 1 Bryson Douglas M (IM 2385
1880 Heron Donald 0 - 1 Gallagher Anthony 2020
1870 Wallace David 0 - 1 Doyle James 1975
1855 Russell David ½ - ½ Gillespie Dave L 1750
1765 Moretta Brian 0 - 1 MacConnell Pat 1690
1740 Tate Alan 1 - 0 Theodoreson Malcolm 1550
1½ - 4½
4 Crowwood "B" 6 Kirkcaldy
1585 MacRae James S 0 - 1 Burnett Andrew B 2235
1595 Wynn Peter J 0 - 1 Pyrich George D 2065
1235 Haggarty Nat W 0 - 1 Fyfe Graeme S S 2035
Not Given A - H Thomson Thomas 1805 Away Win by Default
Not Given A - H Saxton Gavin 1715 Away Win by Default
Not Given A - H Pearson Walter J 1680 Away Win by Default
0 - 6
8 Edin/West 5 Grangemouth
2275 Grant Jonathan I M 1 - 0 Robertson Ian C 2115
2195 Khan Kalimullah 0 - 1 Mather Walter 1985
2130 Farrell Neil R 0 - 1 Will Douglas 1915
2075 MacInally Pat 1 - 0 Feighan Kevin 1840
1985 MacNally Bruce 1 - 0 Washington Ian 1280
1665 Redpath Joe 0 - 1 Ross James W 0
3 - 3
7 Aberdeen 2 Castlehill A
*** V Void/Double default ***
0 - 0
8 Edin/West 4 Crowwood "B"
2275 Grant Jonathan I M H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
2195 Khan Kalimullah 1 - 0 MacRae James S 1585
2130 Farrell Neil R H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
2075 MacInally Pat H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
1985 MacNally Bruce H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
1665 Redpath Joe 1 - 0 Haggarty Nat W 1235
6 - 0
6 Kirkcaldy 1 Crowwood "A"
2235 Burnett Andrew B ½ - ½ Bryson Douglas M (IM 2385
2065 Pyrich George D 1 - 0 Gallagher Anthony 2020
2035 Fyfe Graeme S S ½ - ½ Doyle James 1975
1805 Thomson Thomas 0 - 1 Gillespie Dave L 1750
1715 Saxton Gavin 1 - 0 MacConnell Pat 1690
1680 Pearson Walter J 1 - 0 Theodoreson Malcolm 1550
4 - 2
5 Grangemouth 3 Musselburgh
2115 Robertson Ian C 0 - 1 Konarski Jannic 1875
1985 Mather Walter 0 - 1 Heron Donald 1880
1915 Will Douglas 0 - 1 Wallace David 1870
1840 Feighan Kevin 0 - 1 Russell David 1855
1280 Washington Ian 0 - 1 Moretta Brian 1765
0 Ross James W 0 - 1 Tate Alan 1740
0 - 6
8 Edin/West 3 Musselburgh
2275 Grant Jonathan I M 0 - 1 Campbell Eoin S 1895
2130 Farrell Neil R 1 - 0 Heron Donald 1880
2075 MacInally Pat ½ - ½ Vangelov Peter 1810
1985 MacNally Bruce 1 - 0 Tate Alan 1740
1750 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1 - 0 Forbes Alistair 1575
1380 Whalen Ron N H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
4½ - 1½
7 Aberdeen 4 Crowwood "B"
2120 Berry Neil M 1 - 0 Gillespie Dave L 1750
1910 Cavanagh Mike 1 - 0 Fisher James R 1710
1825 Coffey Thomas 1 - 0 MacConnell Pat 1690
1810 Donaghay Michael R 1 - 0 Watson John 1650
1775 Eltahir Amir 1 - 0 MacRae James S 1585
1775 Clifford John ½ - ½ Theodoreson Malcolm 1550
5½ - ½
1 Crowwood "A" 5 Grangemouth
2385 Bryson Douglas M (IM 1 - 0 Robertson Ian C 2115
2030 Nolan Graeme ½ - ½ Mather Walter 1985
2020 Gallagher Anthony 1 - 0 Will Douglas 1915
1975 Doyle James 1 - 0 Feighan Kevin 1840
1965 Paul Rabindra 1 - 0 Watson James Philip 1610
1860 Hopper Paul D H - A Ross James W 0 Home Win by Default
5½ - ½
2 Castlehill A 3 Musselburgh
1825 Mooney Graham ½ - ½ Campbell Eoin S 1895
1665 Nicol Craig S 0 - 1 Heron Donald 1880
1515 Chalmers Martin M 0 - 1 Vangelov Peter 1810
1365 Gow Robert 0 - 1 Tate Alan 1740
Not Given A - H Forbes Alistair 1575 Away Win by Default
Not Given V - V Not Given Void/Double Default
½ - 4½
7 Aberdeen 1 Crowwood "A"
2120 Berry Neil M 0 - 1 Bryson Douglas M (IM 2385
1910 Cavanagh Mike 0 - 1 Nolan Graeme 2030
1825 Coffey Thomas 0 - 1 Gallagher Anthony 2020
1810 Donaghay Michael R 0 - 1 Doyle James 1975
1775 Eltahir Amir 0 - 1 Paul Rabindra 1965
1775 Clifford John 0 - 1 Hopper Paul D 1860
0 - 6
6 Kirkcaldy 7 Aberdeen
2035 Fyfe Graeme S S 0 - 1 Shepherd Mike 1950
1895 Crockart George N 1 - 0 Cavanagh Mike 1910
1865 Crockart Scott 1 - 0 Donaghay Michael R 1810
1805 Thomson Thomas ½ - ½ Clifford John 1775
1715 Saxton Gavin 1 - 0 MacKay George 1670
1680 Pearson Walter J 0 - 1 Wilson William A 1640
3½ - 2½
1 Crowwood "A" 8 Edin/West
2385 Bryson Douglas M (IM 0 - 1 Grant Jonathan I M 2275
2335 Mannion Stephen R (I 1 - 0 Farrell Neil R 2130
2230 Norris Alan 1 - 0 MacInally Pat 2075
2220 Muir Andrew J (IM) 1 - 0 MacNally Bruce 1985
2030 Nolan Graeme 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1665
2020 Gallagher Anthony 1 - 0 MacDonald Paul 1650
4 - 2
4 Crowwood "B" 5 Grangemouth
1975 Doyle James 1 - 0 Robertson Ian C 2115
1860 Hopper Paul D 1 - 0 Watson James Philip 1610
1875 Melvin Les T 1 - 0 Paterson Dick 1525
1750 Gillespie Dave L 1 - 0 Gray B William 1435
1650 Watson John 1 - 0 Hamilton Armour 1170
1710 Fisher James R H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
6 - 0
5 Grangemouth 2 Castlehill A
2115 Robertson Ian C 1 - 0 Kleppang David L 1910
1985 Mather Walter A - H Mooney Graham 1825 Away Win by Default
1610 Watson James Philip 0 - 1 MacNab Ian A 1740
1525 Paterson Dick 0 - 1 Chalmers Paul A 1605
1170 Hamilton Armour 0 - 1 Chalmers Martin M 1515
Not Given A - H Noble Ray 1515 Away Win by Default
1 - 5
6 Kirkcaldy 8 Edin/West
2035 Fyfe Graeme S S 0 - 1 Grant Jonathan I M 2275
1895 Crockart George N 0 - 1 Farrell Neil R 2130
1865 Crockart Scott ½ - ½ MacInally Pat 2075
1805 Thomson Thomas 0 - 1 MacNally Bruce 1985
1715 Saxton Gavin ½ - ½ Redpath Joe 1665
1680 Pearson Walter J 1 - 0 MacDonald Paul 1650
2 - 4
3 Musselburgh 7 Aberdeen
1915 Burnett Walter ½ - ½ Shepherd Mike 1950
1895 Campbell Eoin S 1 - 0 Cavanagh Mike 1910
1810 Vangelov Peter 0 - 1 Donaghay Michael R 1810
1740 Tate Alan ½ - ½ Clifford John 1775
1695 Stevens Ian 0 - 1 MacKay George 1670
1405 Pirrie Gregor 0 - 1 Wilson William A 1640
2 - 4
Match Cross Table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Pld Pts
1 Crowwood "A" x 5 4½ 5½ 5½ 2 6 4 42 32½
2 Castlehill A 1 x ½ 5 6 30 12½
3 Musselburgh 1½ 4½ x 5½ 6 2 2 1½ 42 23
4 Crowwood "B" ½ ½ x 6 0 ½ 0 36 7½
5 Grangemouth ½ 1 0 0 x 4½ 2 3 42 11
6 Kirkcaldy 4 4 6 1½ x 3½ 2 36 21
7 Aberdeen 0 4 5½ 4 2½ x 6 42 22
8 Edin/West 2 0 4½ 6 3 4 0 x 42 19½
*** Team 1 Crowwood "A" ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3332 Bryson Douglas M (IM) 2385 SHCW 7 5½
9315 Norris Alan 2230 CWST 3 2
7691 Nolan Graeme 2030 J19 SHCW 5 3½
4322 Henderson John B 2025 CW 2 1½
3788 Doyle James 1975 SHCW 5 4½
3934 Fisher James R 1710 CW 1 1
4079 Gillespie Dave L 1750 CWOB 3 2½
4978 MacConnell Pat 1690 CW 3 2
4019 Gallagher Anthony 2020 SHCW 5 4
6223 Theodoreson Malcolm W 1550 CCCW 2 0
10019 Paul Rabindra 1965 CW 2 2
4381 Hopper Paul D 1860 J18 BASH 2 2
4858 Mannion Stephen R (IM) 2335 CW 1 1
5400 Muir Andrew J (IM) 2220 SHCW 1 1
*** Team 2 Castlehill A ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3509 Clapham Robert E 1975 CH 1 0
4612 Kleppang David L 1910 CH 2 1
7382 Mooney Graham 1825 CH 3 1½
5192 MacNab Ian A 1740 CH 2 1
3478 Chalmers Paul A 1605 CH 2 1
3477 Chalmers Martin M 1515 CH 3 1
5485 Nicol Craig S 1665 CH 1 0
4148 Gow Robert 1365 CHDV 1 0
8657 Noble Ray 1515 CH 1 1
*** Team 3 Musselburgh ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
12511 Weng Annegret 2165 WDXK 2 1
5585 Paterson Graham 2145 MUWD 2 1½
4621 Konarski Jannic 1875 WD 4 2
4015 Galbraith Joe 1815 MUBB 2 1½
6191 Tate Alan 1740 J18 WDBN 7 5
5093 MacIntosh Alasdair 1660 WHWD 2 1
4339 Heron Donald 1880 WDED 4 2
6346 Wallace David 1870 FAWD 2 1
5870 Russell David 1855 BAMU 2 1½
5349 Moretta Brian 1765 MU 2 1
3415 Campbell Eoin S 1895 WD 3 2½
7576 Vangelov Peter 1810 EDWD 3 1½
8254 Forbes Alistair 1575 SSWD 2 1
3352 Burnett Walter 1915 KCWD 1 ½
8679 Stevens Ian 1695 J18 MUWD 1 0
5643 Pirrie Gregor 1405 WDBS 1 0
*** Team 4 Crowwood "B" ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4079 Gillespie Dave L 1750 CWOB 3 1
4978 MacConnell Pat 1690 CW 2 ½
6401 Watson John 1650 CNCW 4 1
4817 MacRae James S 1585 CW 5 ½
5658 Pollock Andrew 1430 CWCN 2 0
4224 Haggarty Nat W 1235 CW 4 0
3788 Doyle James 1975 SHCW 2 1
3934 Fisher James R 1710 CW 3 1
6556 Wynn Peter J 1595 DL 1 0
6223 Theodoreson Malcolm W 1550 CCCW 1 ½
4381 Hopper Paul D 1860 J18 BASH 1 1
5244 Melvin Les T 1875 SHCW 1 1
*** Team 5 Grangemouth ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5811 Robertson Ian C 2115 DLWD 7 2½
6473 Will Douglas 1915 GRWD 5 2
6399 Watson James Philip 1610 GR 5 1
9179 Gray B William 1435 GRWD 3 1
10183 Washington Ian 1280 KRDL 4 1
11848 Ross James W 0 J13 KRDL 5 2
4893 Mather Walter 1985 DLGR 4 1½
3887 Feighan Kevin 1840 GRWD 3 0
9328 Paterson Dick 1525 GR 2 0
7682 Hamilton Armour 1170 POGR 2 0
*** Team 6 Kirkcaldy ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3349 Burnett Andrew B 2235 KCWD 4 2½
5692 Pyrich George D 2065 KCGN 4 2
4008 Fyfe Graeme S S 2035 KC 6 3
6257 Thomson Thomas 1805 KC 6 3
8807 Saxton Gavin 1715 KC 6 4
5607 Pearson Walter J 1680 KCGN 6 4
11922 Crockart Scott 1865 J17 KC 2 1½
12926 Crockart George N 1895 KC 2 1
*** Team 7 Aberdeen ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3187 Berry Neil M 2120 J20 BNAU 3 1½
5969 Shepherd Mike 1950 BPBA 3 2½
3468 Cavanagh Mike 1910 BA 5 1½
3548 Coffey Thomas 1825 RGHC 3 1
3759 Donaghay Michael R 1810 BAHB 5 3
3534 Clifford John 1775 ATBA 5 2½
11475 Eltahir Amir 1775 NEW BAAT 2 1
4783 MacKay George 1670 RGEW 2 1
6516 Wilson William A 1640 BA 2 2
*** Team 8 Edin/West ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4168 Grant Jonathan I M 2275 EWSO 5 4
12513 Khan Kalimullah 2195 EWXK 2 1
3881 Farrell Neil R 2130 EW 5 3
9027 MacInally Pat 2075 EW 5 3
5194 MacNally Bruce 1985 EWWD 5 4
8350 Redpath Joe 1665 J12 EW 4 2½
7993 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1750 J17 EWSM 1 1
6443 Whalen Ron N 1380 EW 1 1
11408 MacDonald Paul 1650 EWEU 2 0