Season 1998 Catchpell House Summer Cup
1 Corstor 2 2 Civil Serv 1
1325 Bruce Douglas 0 - 1 Brown Gerry 1545
1310 Douglas Alexander G 1 - 0 Heatlie Douglas S 1525
1300 Gourlay Brian 0 - 1 Bate Simon 1525
1185 Watson David 1 - 0 Gilbert Robert 1250
1000 Crerar Bruce 0 - 1 Bridgeman Graham 1200
830 Crerar James D 1 - 0 Gilroy Michael 1165
3 - 3
3 Deans White 4 Edin West
1740 Dickie Jonathan 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1665
1685 Murray Stephen 1 - 0 Seywright Alan A 1445
1475 Comrie Robert 0 - 1 Grant William M 1410
1435 Miller Ross 0 - 1 Hadi Justin 0
0 Wood Andrew 0 - 1 Grant Iain C 1225
1085 Matthews Colin 1 - 0 Balfour John 1030
2 - 4
5 Corstor 1 6 Mussel 2
1510 Dowling Richard K 1 - 0 Capaldi Alex 1610
1495 Elders Peter 0 - 1 Loudon James M 1460
1460 Burns David 1 - 0 MacFarlane Alex 1415
1425 Bate Joe 1 - 0 Colquhoun William 1225
1360 MacKay Roddy J 0 - 1 Hope Iain D 1210
1310 Gilbert Harry ½ - ½ Knox David 1085
3½ - 2½
7 Civ Serv 2 8 Wand Drag 2
1820 Melville Alan G ½ - ½ MacIntosh Alasdair 1660
1610 Miller Patrick M ½ - ½ Murphy George A A 1595
0 Pannell John 1 - 0 Falconer William 1565
1385 Kirk Steven 1 - 0 Sanderson Gary 1470
1265 MacCrae John 0 - 1 Miller Saul 0
905 Woods Brian 0 - 1 Laurie Stephen D 0
3 - 3
9 Mussel 1 10 Sandy Bells
2145 Paterson Graham 1 - 0 Duncan Nicholas 1100
1855 Russell David 1 - 0 Wallace Mike 1030
1795 Soutar Gavin I 1 - 0 MacLean Fiona 990
1765 Moretta Brian 1 - 0 Muir Lindsay 925
1730 Chia Mark 1 - 0 Taylor D 0
1695 Stevens Ian 1 - 0 Flannagan Thomas 0
6 - 0
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 2
11 Dragons 3 12 Pent Hills
1810 Vangelov Peter 0 - 1 Morrison Ian C 1845
1420 Shapland David ½ - ½ Davies Gordon H 1790
1420 Hepburn James 0 - 1 Ewington Lenny C 1600
1350 Ritchie Stephen 0 - 1 Ridland Lindsay S 1465
1280 MacIntosh Sally A ½ - ½ Wallace Jim 1410
1245 Duncan Brian 0 - 1 Fenoulhet Ray G 1375
1 - 5
13 Lasswade 4 Edin West
1760 Findlay Jack 0 - 1 MacNally Bruce 1985
1640 Flockhart Hugh S 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1665
1430 MacIntosh Alan 0 - 1 Deas William B 1575
1385 Campbell Ian 0 - 1 Seywright Alan A 1445
1305 MacArdle Malcolm 0 - 1 Grant William M 1410
1125 Middleton Peter D 0 - 1 Hadi Justin 0
0 - 6
14 Edin West 2 15 Balerno
1835 MacNaughton Alistair 0 - 1 Smith Eric P 1780
1715 Campbell Alistair W 1 - 0 MacKay Iain 1440
1650 MacDonald Paul 1 - 0 Goldie Peter 1390
1535 Mayo Kevin 1 - 0 Watt David B 1245
1380 Whalen Ron N 1 - 0 Bond David E 1240
1430 Deas John H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
5 - 1
16 Badgers B 1 Corstor 2
1250 Boylan Vincent 0 - 1 Bruce Douglas 1325
1250 Blythe Henry ½ - ½ Gourlay Brian 1300
1190 Flannigan Jon 1 - 0 Watson David 1185
1175 Glidden Alistair 1 - 0 Crerar Bruce 1000
1050 Liddle Robert ½ - ½ Crerar James D 830
915 MacColl George 0 - 1 King David 0
3 - 3
17 Livingston 18 Wand Drag 1
1500 Petch Rab 0 - 1 Campbell Eoin S 1895
1425 Thomson George 0 - 1 Forbes Alistair 1575
1400 Wright Paul ½ - ½ MacGregor Lindsay A 1575
1285 Wright Andrew H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
1255 Robinson Stuart H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
1235 Kerr Graham H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
3½ - 2½
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 3
17 Livingston 12 Pent Hills
1500 Petch Rab ½ - ½ Morrison Ian C 1845
1425 Thomson George 0 - 1 Ewington Lenny C 1600
1400 Wright Paul ½ - ½ Wallace Jim 1410
1325 Dunsmore Alan 1 - 0 Fenoulhet Ray G 1375
1285 Wright Andrew 1 - 0 Orr Jim 1020
1235 Kerr Graham 1 - 0 MacFarlane George C 940
4 - 2
7 Civ Serv 2 4 Edin West
1820 Melville Alan G 0 - 1 MacNally Bruce 1985
1815 Greensmith David 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1665
1795 Prince Alan R 0 - 1 Deas William B 1575
Not Given A - H Seywright Alan A 1445 Away Win by Default
1610 Miller Patrick M 1 - 0 Grant William M 1410
1385 Kirk Steven 0 - 1 Hadi Justin 0
1 - 5
1 Corstor 2 14 Edin West 2
1325 Bruce Douglas 0 - 1 MacDonald Paul 1650
1310 Douglas Alexander G ½ - ½ Mayo Kevin 1535
1300 Gourlay Brian 1 - 0 Deas John 1430
1185 Watson David 1 - 0 Whalen Ron N 1380
1000 Crerar Bruce 0 - 1 Crosbie Stewart 0
830 Crerar James D 0 - 1 Whitelaw James 1005
2½ - 3½
9 Mussel 1 6 Mussel 2
2145 Paterson Graham ½ - ½ Fraser Mark G 1945
1855 Russell David 1 - 0 Capaldi Alex 1610
1795 Soutar Gavin I 1 - 0 MacFarlane Alex 1415
1765 Moretta Brian 1 - 0 Colquhoun William 1225
1695 Stevens Ian 1 - 0 Hope Iain D 1210
1485 Barron Vince 1 - 0 Knox David 1085
5½ - ½
11 Dragons 3 5 Corstor 1
1875 Konarski Jannic ½ - ½ Dowling Richard K 1510
1875 Sloan S Elliot 1 - 0 Elders Peter 1495
1420 Shapland David 1 - 0 Bate Joe 1425
1405 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 MacKay Roddy J 1360
1245 Duncan Brian 0 - 1 Gilbert Harry 1310
1245 MacFarland Peter H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
4½ - 1½
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 4
18 Wand Drag 1 16 Badgers B
1895 Campbell Eoin S 1 - 0 Boylan Vincent 1250
1880 Heron Donald 1 - 0 Blythe Henry 1250
1615 Stuart Duncan 1 - 0 Flannigan Jon 1190
1590 Platts William G C 0 - 1 Glidden Alistair 1175
1575 Forbes Alistair 1 - 0 Liddle Robert 1050
1510 Hutchison Colin J 1 - 0 Thomson I 0
5 - 1
16 Badgers B 11 Dragons 3
1250 Boylan Vincent 0 - 1 Konarski Jannic 1875
1250 Blythe Henry 0 - 1 Vangelov Peter 1810
1190 Flannigan Jon 0 - 1 Shapland David 1420
1175 Glidden Alistair 0 - 1 Hepburn James 1420
1050 Liddle Robert 0 - 1 Pirrie Gregor 1405
0 Thomson I 1 - 0 Duncan Brian 1245
1 - 5
15 Balerno 8 Wand Drag 2
1780 Smith Eric P 0 - 1 Kynoch Richard J P 1825
0 Sinclair Edmond ½ - ½ Montgomery David C 1675
1440 MacKay Iain 0 - 1 MacIntosh Alasdair 1660
1245 Watt David B ½ - ½ Murphy George A A 1595
1240 Bond David E 0 - 1 Sanderson Gary 1470
0 Muneer Kashif 0 - 1 Laurie Stephen D 0
1 - 5
9 Mussel 1 17 Livingston
2145 Paterson Graham 1 - 0 Petch Rab 1500
1855 Russell David ½ - ½ Thomson George 1425
1795 Soutar Gavin I 0 - 1 Wright Paul 1400
1765 Moretta Brian 1 - 0 Dunsmore Alan 1325
1695 Stevens Ian 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
1550 Anderson Dennis R B 1 - 0 Kerr Graham 1235
4½ - 1½
2 Civil Serv 1 13 Lasswade
1525 Bate Simon 0 - 1 Findlay Jack 1760
1525 Heatlie Douglas S 1 - 0 Flockhart Hugh S 1640
1250 Gilbert Robert 1 - 0 Nisbet Charles 1450
1200 Bridgeman Graham 1 - 0 MacIntosh Alan 1430
1165 Gilroy Michael ½ - ½ Campbell Ian 1385
1160 Beattie Alex J 1 - 0 Middleton Peter D 1125
4½ - 1½
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 5
1 Corstor 2 4 Edin West
1325 Bruce Douglas 0 - 1 Redpath Joe 1665
1310 Douglas Alexander G 0 - 1 Seywright Alan A 1445
1300 Gourlay Brian 1 - 0 Grant William M 1410
1185 Watson David 0 - 1 Hadi Justin 0
1000 Crerar Bruce 0 - 1 Grant Iain C 1225
830 Crerar James D 1 - 0 Balfour John 1030
2 - 4
3 Deans White 10 Sandy Bells
1685 Murray Stephen 0 - 1 Chandler Geoff T 1835
1475 Comrie Robert 1 - 0 Wallace Mike 1030
0 Wood Andrew 1 - 0 MacLean Fiona 990
1260 Tonner Hugh 0 - 1 Muir Lindsay 925
1085 Matthews Colin 1 - 0 Burns R 0
Not Given V - V Not Given Void/Double Default
3 - 2
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 6
Table Order = M pts
----------Boards (6 per Match)--------
----Matches---- ---Played--- --Defaults-- -Score-
Pos Team P W L D Pts W L D W L D Bds %
1 4 Edin West 4 4 0 0 8 18 5 0 1 0 0 19 79
2 9 Mussel 1 3 3 0 0 6 15 1 2 0 0 0 16 89
3 14 Edin West 2 2 2 0 0 4 7 3 1 1 0 0 8½ 71
4 11 Dragons 3 3 2 1 0 4 8 6 3 1 0 0 10½ 58
5 17 Livingston 3 2 1 0 4 4 7 4 3 0 0 9 50
6 8 Wand Drag 2 2 1 0 1 3 6 2 4 0 0 0 8 67
7 2 Civil Serv 1 2 1 0 1 3 7 4 1 0 0 0 7½ 63
8 18 Wand Drag 1 2 1 1 0 2 7 1 1 0 3 0 7½ 63
9 12 Pent Hills 2 1 1 0 2 5 3 4 0 0 0 7 58
10 1 Corstor 2 4 0 2 2 2 9 12 3 0 0 0 10½ 44
11 5 Corstor 1 2 1 1 0 2 4 5 2 0 1 0 5 42
12 3 Deans White 2 1 1 0 2 5 6 0 0 1 0 5 42
13 7 Civ Serv 2 2 0 1 1 1 3 6 2 0 1 0 4 33
14 16 Badgers B 3 0 2 1 1 4 12 2 0 0 0 5 28
15 6 Mussel 2 2 0 2 0 0 2 8 2 0 0 0 3 25
16 15 Balerno 2 0 2 0 0 1 8 2 0 1 0 2 17
17 10 Sandy Bells 2 0 2 0 0 2 9 0 0 1 0 2 17
18 13 Lasswade 2 0 2 0 0 1 10 1 0 0 0 1½ 13
-- -- -- -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ----
Tots for x-check 44 19 19 6 44 108 108 34 6 8 0 131
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 7
Match Cross Table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Pld Pts
1 Corstor 2 x 3 2 2½ 3 24 10½
2 Civil Serv 1 3 x 4½ 12 7½
3 Deans White x 2 3 12 5
4 Edin West 4 4 x 5 6 24 19
5 Corstor 1 x 3½ 1½ 12 5
6 Mussel 2 2½ x ½ 12 3
7 Civ Serv 2 1 x 3 12 4
8 Wand Drag 2 3 x 5 12 8
9 Mussel 1 5½ x 6 4½ 18 16
10 Sandy Bells 2 0 x 12 2
11 Dragons 3 4½ x 1 5 18 10½
12 Pent Hills 5 x 2 12 7
13 Lasswade 1½ 0 x 12 1½
14 Edin West 2 3½ x 5 12 8½
15 Balerno 1 1 x 12 2
16 Badgers B 3 1 x 1 18 5
17 Livingston 1½ 4 x 3½ 18 9
18 Wand Drag 1 5 2½ x 12 7½
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 8
*** Team 1 Corstor 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
7095 Bruce Douglas 1325 CO 4 1
3782 Douglas Alexander G 1310 CO 3 1½
8390 Gourlay Brian 1300 CO 4 2½
9743 Watson David 1185 CO 4 2
10620 Crerar Bruce 1000 CO 4 0
9746 Crerar James D 830 CO 4 2½
12404 King David 0 CO 1 1
*** Team 2 Civil Serv 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
7921 Brown Gerry 1545 CS 1 1
4313 Heatlie Douglas S 1525 CSWD 2 1
3143 Bate Simon 1525 CS 2 1
9178 Gilbert Robert 1250 CS 2 1
9033 Bridgeman Graham 1200 CS 2 2
11146 Gilroy Michael 1165 CS 2 ½
3158 Beattie Alex J 1160 CS 1 1
*** Team 3 Deans White ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3728 Dickie Jonathan 1740 J20 DSBK 1 0
12158 Murray Stephen 1685 NEW DSLV 2 1
11592 Comrie Robert 1475 DSLV 2 1
10513 Miller Ross 1435 DSLV 1 0
12549 Wood Andrew 0 DS 2 1
11594 Matthews Colin 1085 DS 2 2
11593 Tonner Hugh 1260 DS 1 0
*** Team 4 Edin West ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
8350 Redpath Joe 1665 J12 EW 4 4
5943 Seywright Alan A 1445 EWCC 4 3
4174 Grant William M 1410 EW 4 2
12490 Hadi Justin 0 EW 4 4
4167 Grant Iain C 1225 EW 2 2
3103 Balfour John 1030 EW 2 0
5194 MacNally Bruce 1985 EWWD 2 2
3705 Deas William B 1575 EW 2 2
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 9
*** Team 5 Corstor 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3785 Dowling Richard K 1510 CO 2 1½
3842 Elders Peter 1495 CO 2 0
3354 Burns David 1460 CO 1 1
8391 Bate Joe 1425 CO 2 1
5114 MacKay Roddy J 1360 DLCO 2 0
4070 Gilbert Harry 1310 CO 2 1½
*** Team 6 Mussel 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3432 Capaldi Alex 1610 MU 2 0
4724 Loudon James M 1460 MU 1 1
9511 MacFarlane Alex 1415 MU 2 0
9509 Colquhoun William 1225 MU 2 0
4379 Hope Iain D 1210 MU 2 1
11599 Knox David 1085 PLMU 2 ½
3986 Fraser Mark G 1945 MUWD 1 ½
*** Team 7 Civ Serv 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
9060 Melville Alan G 1820 CSWD 2 ½
5270 Miller Patrick M 1610 CS 2 1½
13076 Pannell John 0 CS 1 1
4609 Kirk Steven 1385 CSMU 2 1
8757 MacCrae John 1265 CS 1 0
12391 Woods Brian 905 NEW CS 1 0
7914 Greensmith David 1815 CS 1 0
10488 Prince Alan R 1795 CS 1 0
3084 Austin Rudolf J 1665 EDCS 0 0
*** Team 8 Wand Drag 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5093 MacIntosh Alasdair 1660 WHWD 2 1½
12163 Murphy George A A 1595 NEW EDWD 2 1
3872 Falconer William 1565 WD 1 0
5894 Sanderson Gary 1470 WD 2 1
12564 Miller Saul 0 WD 1 1
4653 Laurie Stephen D 0 WD 2 2
4629 Kynoch Richard J P 1825 EDWD 1 1
10572 Montgomery David C 1675 EDWD 1 ½
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 10
*** Team 9 Mussel 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5585 Paterson Graham 2145 MUWD 3 2½
5870 Russell David 1855 BAMU 3 2½
6065 Soutar Gavin I 1795 MUWD 3 2
5349 Moretta Brian 1765 MU 3 3
12217 Chia Mark 1730 NEW EUWD 1 1
8679 Stevens Ian 1695 J18 MUWD 3 3
7839 Barron Vince 1485 MU 1 1
3044 Anderson Dennis R B 1550 MU 1 1
*** Team 10 Sandy Bells ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
12167 Duncan Nicholas 1100 NEW SB 1 0
9443 Wallace Mike 1030 NEW SB 2 0
10604 MacLean Fiona 990 NEW SBWD 2 0
9444 Muir Lindsay 925 SB 2 1
13185 Taylor D 0 SB 1 0
12426 Flannagan Thomas 0 SB 1 0
3483 Chandler Geoff T 1835 SB 1 1
13184 Burns R 0 SB 1 0
*** Team 11 Dragons 3 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
7576 Vangelov Peter 1810 EDWD 2 1
12439 Shapland David 1420 EUWD 3 2½
9041 Hepburn James 1420 WD 2 1
9049 Ritchie Stephen 1350 PLWD 1 0
7712 MacIntosh Sally A 1280 WHWD 1 ½
9578 Duncan Brian 1245 SBWD 3 0
4621 Konarski Jannic 1875 WD 2 1½
6012 Sloan S Elliot 1875 WD 1 1
5643 Pirrie Gregor 1405 WDBS 2 2
5035 MacFarland Peter 1245 WD 1 1
*** Team 12 Pent Hills ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5375 Morrison Ian C 1845 PH 2 1½
3688 Davies Gordon H 1790 PHCC 1 ½
3865 Ewington Lenny C 1600 PH 2 2
7097 Ridland Lindsay S 1465 PH 1 1
6354 Wallace Jim 1410 PH 2 1
3891 Fenoulhet Ray G 1375 PH 2 1
11542 Orr Jim 1020 NEW PH 1 0
4771 MacFarlane George C 940 STPH 1 0
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 11
*** Team 13 Lasswade ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
9508 Findlay Jack 1760 LS 2 1
3950 Flockhart Hugh S 1640 LS 2 0
5092 MacIntosh Alan 1430 LS 2 0
10507 Campbell Ian 1385 LS 2 ½
4952 MacArdle Malcolm 1305 LS 1 0
5254 Middleton Peter D 1125 LS 2 0
10970 Nisbet Charles 1450 LS 1 0
*** Team 14 Edin West 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
11929 MacNaughton Alistair K J 1835 EW 1 0
3403 Campbell Alistair W I 1715 OBEW 1 1
11408 MacDonald Paul 1650 EWEU 2 2
7089 Mayo Kevin 1535 EWSO 2 1½
6443 Whalen Ron N 1380 EW 2 1
3703 Deas John 1430 EW 2 1
12423 Crosbie Stewart 0 EW 1 1
9054 Whitelaw James 1005 EW 1 1
*** Team 15 Balerno ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6033 Smith Eric P 1780 BN 2 1
8000 MacKay Iain 1440 BN 2 0
4108 Goldie Peter 1390 BN 1 0
6415 Watt David B 1245 BN 2 ½
3229 Bond David E 1240 BN 2 0
9446 Sinclair Edmond 0 ED 1 ½
11319 Muneer Kashif 0 J14 BN 1 0
*** Team 16 Badgers B ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
10478 Boylan Vincent 1250 BXED 3 0
10772 Blythe Henry 1250 NEW BX 3 ½
10479 Flannigan Jon 1190 BX 3 1
10774 Glidden Alistair 1175 BX 3 2
10773 Liddle Robert 1050 BX 3 ½
10775 MacColl George 915 BX 1 0
12419 Thomson I 0 BX 2 1
Season 1998 Summer Cup Cr 01/07/98 Proc 01/07/98 01/07/98 Page 12
*** Team 17 Livingston ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5621 Petch Rab 1500 LV 3 ½
10598 Thomson George 1425 LV 3 ½
9587 Wright Paul 1400 J18 LVBK 3 2
11834 Wright Andrew 1285 NEW LV 3 2
5831 Robinson Stuart 1255 LV 1 1
10613 Kerr Graham 1235 LV 3 2
7464 Dunsmore Alan 1325 LV 2 1
*** Team 18 Wand Drag 1 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3415 Campbell Eoin S 1895 WD 2 2
8254 Forbes Alistair 1575 SSWD 2 2
5076 MacGregor Lindsay A 1575 EDWD 1 ½
4339 Heron Donald 1880 WDED 1 1
10514 Stuart Duncan 1615 EDWD 1 1
5650 Platts William G C 1590 STWD 1 0
4434 Hutchison Colin J 1510 JPWD 1 1