Results for SNCL Division 3

SNCL Division 3

Played at Dunfermline ending on 30/04/2009

Results compiled by Andrew Howie

Grading calculations last updated - 24/12/2008

SNCL Division 3 League Table

								Boards
			Matches					Played			Defaults			Score
Pos	Team	Team Name	P	W	D	L	Pts	W	D	L	W	D	L	Boards	%
1	1	Claymores	2	2	0	0	4	7	3	0	0	0	0	8½	85
2	7	Greenwood	2	2	0	0	4	7	2	1	0	0	0	8	80
3	6	Oban	2	1	1	0	3	6	1	3	0	0	0	6½	65
4	8	Irvine	2	1	0	1	2	4	3	3	0	0	0	5½	55
5	4	Edinburgh 2	2	1	0	1	2	3	2	5	0	0	0	4	40
6	5	CS BOS 2	2	0	1	1	1	2	2	6	0	0	0	3	30
7	3	Hamilton C	2	0	0	2	0	3	0	7	0	0	0	3	30
8	2	Stonehaven	2	0	0	2	0	1	1	8	0	0	0	1½	15
			16	7	2	7	16	33	14	33	0	0	0	40

SNCL Division 3 Crosstable

Team Name 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Plyd Boards
1 Claymores X 4½    4             2 8½

2 Stonehaven ½ X             1    2 1½

3 Hamilton C       X 2    1       2 3

4 Edinburgh 2 1    3 X             2 4

5 CS BOS 2             X 2½    ½ 2 3

6 Oban       4    2½ X       2 6½

7 Greenwood    4             X 4 2 8

8 Irvine             4½    1 X 2 5½

SNCL Division 3 Match Results

Bd Grade Claymores (1) vs (2) Stonehaven Grade Comments

1 2086 Nolan, Graeme A 1 - 0 Grant, David 1808 Home Win

2 1885 Ferry, Edward 1 - 0 Harrold, Bruce T 1684 Home Win

3 1751 Dempsey, John ½ - ½ Emery, Keith 1543 Draw

4 1626 Voghouei, Bahloul 1 - 0 Bridges, David 1385 Home Win

5 1424 Kerridge, Simon 1 - 0 Emery, Nicola 332 Home Win

4½ - ½

Bd Grade Hamilton C (3) vs (4) Edinburgh 2 Grade Comments

1 0 Reid, Colin 1 - 0 Horne, Robert 1488 Home Win

2 996 Hampton, Chris R 0 - 1 Scott, Jonathan 1388 Away Win

3 944 Latta, Lawrence 0 - 1 Murdochy, Shivan 1216 Away Win

4 890 Childs, Robert 1 - 0 He, Ben 904 Home Win

5 983 Thomas, Matthew R 0 - 1 Skillen, Fergus 717 Away Win

2 - 3

Bd Grade CS BOS 2 (5) vs (6) Oban Grade Comments

1 1601 Chapman, Nigel ½ - ½ Campbell, Duncan A F 1857 Draw

2 1509 Russell, Graeme R 0 - 1 Campbell, Alistair W I 1776 Away Win

3 1371 MacDonald, Gordon J 1 - 0 Flockhart, Hugh S 1767 Home Win

4 1355 Turner, James 0 - 1 Coope, Derek W 1469 Away Win

5 1222 West, Nicholas C 1 - 0 Robinson, Jeffrey M 1059 Home Win

2½ - 2½

Bd Grade Greenwood (7) vs (8) Irvine Grade Comments

1 2062 Frew, Elliot 1 - 0 Wiltshire, Richard 2018 Home Win

2 1619 McCurley, Arthur 1 - 0 Gourlay, Robert 1572 Home Win

3 1625 Gillespie, David M ½ - ½ Loughran, Robert 1542 Draw

4 1571 McGovern, Patrick 1 - 0 Harkins, George 1283 Home Win

5 1237 Gillespie, David P ½ - ½ Forbes, Graeme 1253 Draw

4 - 1

Bd Grade Oban (6) vs (3) Hamilton C Grade Comments

1 1857 Campbell, Duncan A F 1 - 0 Reid, Colin 0 Home Win

2 1776 Campbell, Alistair W I 1 - 0 Hampton, Chris R 996 Home Win

3 1767 Flockhart, Hugh S 1 - 0 Latta, Lawrence 944 Home Win

4 1469 Coope, Derek W 1 - 0 Childs, Robert 890 Home Win

5 1059 Robinson, Jeffrey M 0 - 1 Thomas, Matthew R 983 Away Win

4 - 1

Bd Grade Irvine (8) vs (5) CS BOS 2 Grade Comments

1 2018 Wiltshire, Richard 1 - 0 Chapman, Nigel 1601 Home Win

2 1572 Gourlay, Robert 1 - 0 Russell, Graeme R 1509 Home Win

3 1542 Loughran, Robert ½ - ½ MacDonald, Gordon J 1371 Draw

4 1283 Harkins, George 1 - 0 Turner, James 1355 Home Win

5 1253 Forbes, Graeme 1 - 0 West, Nicholas C 1222 Home Win

4½ - ½

Bd Grade Edinburgh 2 (4) vs (1) Claymores Grade Comments

1 1488 Horne, Robert 0 - 1 Nolan, Graeme A 2086 Away Win

2 1388 Scott, Jonathan ½ - ½ Ferry, Edward 1885 Draw

3 1216 Murdochy, Shivan ½ - ½ Dempsey, John 1751 Draw

4 904 He, Ben 0 - 1 Voghouei, Bahloul 1626 Away Win

5 717 Skillen, Fergus 0 - 1 Kerridge, Simon 1424 Away Win

1 - 4

Bd Grade Stonehaven (2) vs (7) Greenwood Grade Comments

1 1808 Grant, David 0 - 1 Frew, Elliot 2062 Away Win

2 1684 Harrold, Bruce T 1 - 0 McCurley, Arthur 1619 Home Win

3 1543 Emery, Keith 0 - 1 Gillespie, David M 1625 Away Win

4 1385 Bridges, David 0 - 1 McGovern, Patrick 1571 Away Win

5 332 Emery, Nicola 0 - 1 Gillespie, David P 1237 Away Win

1 - 4

SNCL Division 3 Team Results

Team 1 - Claymores
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Ferry, Edward GM - 1885 3912 1½ 2 1591 1½ 2 1.668 -0.168 1784

3 Dempsey, John GMBD - 1751 6685 1 2 1556 1 2 1.502 -0.502 1556

1 Nolan, Graeme A SH - 2086 7691 2 2 1747 2 2 1.752 0.248 2147

5 Kerridge, Simon BD - 1424 15294 2 2 1024 1 1 0.918 0.082 1424

4 Voghouei, Bahloul GM - 1626 18307 2 2 1306 2 2 1.716 0.284 1705

Team 2 - Stonehaven
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Harrold, Bruce T SZOB - 1684 4277 1 2 1752 1 2 0.834 0.166 1752

3 Emery, Keith SZB2 - 1543 9859 ½ 2 1688 ½ 2 0.623 -0.123 1495

1 Grant, David SZ - 1808 13856 0 2 2074 0 2 0.353 -0.353 1674

5 Emery, Nicola SZB2 J14 332 14541 0 2 732 0 0 0.000 0.000 332

4 Bridges, David B2 - 1385 15848 0 2 1598 0 2 0.462 -0.462 1198

Team 3 - Hamilton C
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Hampton, Chris R HAWD - 996 4243 0 2 1396 0 1 0.082 -0.082 996

3 Latta, Lawrence HA - 944 4648 0 2 1344 0 1 0.082 -0.082 944

5 Thomas, Matthew R GIMN J14 983 15984 1 2 948 1 2 1.089 -0.089 948

1 Reid, Colin HA - 0 16178 1 2 1685 1 2 0 0 1685

4 Childs, Robert HA J10 890 16934 1 2 1157 1 2 0.400 0.600 1157

Team 4 - Edinburgh 2
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Scott, Jonathan J2 J13 1388 16254 1½ 2 1392 1½ 2 0.995 0.505 1585

5 Skillen, Fergus SR J 9 717 17726 1 2 1100 1 2 0.184 0.816 1100

4 He, Ben SN J11 904 17821 0 2 1157 0 2 0.439 -0.439 757

3 Murdochy, Shivan J2 J13 1216 17940 1½ 2 1393 1½ 2 1.183 0.317 1586

1 Horne, Robert ED NEW 1488 18900 0 2 1816 0 2 0.269 -0.269 1415

Team 5 - CS BOS 2
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
3 MacDonald, Gordon J CS - 1371 4765 1½ 2 1654 1½ 2 0.361 1.139 1848

1 Chapman, Nigel SB - 1601 7563 ½ 2 1929 ½ 2 0.269 0.231 1736

2 Russell, Graeme R BS - 1509 8748 0 2 1674 0 2 0.587 -0.587 1274

4 Turner, James BS - 1355 11731 0 2 1376 0 2 0.941 -0.941 976

5 West, Nicholas C CS - 1222 18884 1 2 1156 1 2 1.175 -0.175 1156

Team 6 - Oban
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Campbell, Alistair W I EWCW - 1776 3403 2 2 1442 1 1 0.822 0.178 1842

1 Campbell, Duncan A F OB - 1857 3411 1½ 2 1672 1½ 2 1.469 0.031 1865

3 Flockhart, Hugh S LSOB - 1767 3950 1 2 1369 0 1 0.916 -0.916 1369

4 Coope, Derek W OB - 1469 15536 2 2 1212 2 2 1.574 0.426 1612

5 Robinson, Jeffrey M OB - 1059 17971 0 2 1152 0 2 0.748 -0.748 752

Team 7 - Greenwood
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
3 Gillespie, David M GD - 1625 4080 1½ 2 1542 1½ 2 1.227 0.273 1736

2 McCurley, Arthur GD - 1619 4998 1 2 1628 1 2 0.972 0.028 1628

4 McGovern, Patrick GD - 1571 5063 2 2 1334 2 2 1.583 0.417 1734

1 Frew, Elliot GD - 2062 7506 2 2 1913 2 2 1.376 0.624 2313

5 Gillespie, David P AR J14 1237 17274 1½ 2 1045 ½ 1 0.479 0.021 1238

Team 8 - Irvine
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
4 Harkins, George IR - 1283 4263 1 2 1463 1 2 0.560 0.440 1463

3 Loughran, Robert IR - 1542 4725 1 2 1498 1 2 1.106 -0.106 1498

1 Wiltshire, Richard BD - 2018 6517 1 2 1840 1 2 1.355 -0.355 1840

2 Gourlay, Robert KIIR - 1572 7499 1 2 1564 1 2 1.028 -0.028 1564

5 Forbes, Graeme SH - 1253 14990 1½ 2 1280 1½ 2 0.925 0.575 1472

Bd	Grade	Claymores	(1)	vs	(2)	Stonehaven	Grade	Comments
1	2086	Nolan, Graeme A	1	-	0	Grant, David	1808	Home Win
2	1885	Ferry, Edward	1	-	0	Harrold, Bruce T	1684	Home Win
3	1751	Dempsey, John	½	-	½	Emery, Keith	1543	Draw
4	1626	Voghouei, Bahloul	1	-	0	Bridges, David	1385	Home Win
5	1424	Kerridge, Simon	1	-	0	Emery, Nicola	332	Home Win
			4½	-	½

Bd	Grade	Hamilton C	(3)	vs	(4)	Edinburgh 2	Grade	Comments
1	0	Reid, Colin	1	-	0	Horne, Robert	1488	Home Win
2	996	Hampton, Chris R	0	-	1	Scott, Jonathan	1388	Away Win
3	944	Latta, Lawrence	0	-	1	Murdochy, Shivan	1216	Away Win
4	890	Childs, Robert	1	-	0	He, Ben	904	Home Win
5	983	Thomas, Matthew R	0	-	1	Skillen, Fergus	717	Away Win
			2	-	3

Bd	Grade	CS BOS 2	(5)	vs	(6)	Oban	Grade	Comments
1	1601	Chapman, Nigel	½	-	½	Campbell, Duncan A F	1857	Draw
2	1509	Russell, Graeme R	0	-	1	Campbell, Alistair W I	1776	Away Win
3	1371	MacDonald, Gordon J	1	-	0	Flockhart, Hugh S	1767	Home Win
4	1355	Turner, James	0	-	1	Coope, Derek W	1469	Away Win
5	1222	West, Nicholas C	1	-	0	Robinson, Jeffrey M	1059	Home Win
			2½	-	2½

Bd	Grade	Greenwood	(7)	vs	(8)	Irvine	Grade	Comments
1	2062	Frew, Elliot	1	-	0	Wiltshire, Richard	2018	Home Win
2	1619	McCurley, Arthur	1	-	0	Gourlay, Robert	1572	Home Win
3	1625	Gillespie, David M	½	-	½	Loughran, Robert	1542	Draw
4	1571	McGovern, Patrick	1	-	0	Harkins, George	1283	Home Win
5	1237	Gillespie, David P	½	-	½	Forbes, Graeme	1253	Draw
			4	-	1

Team 1 - Claymores
								Grading Performance
Pool	Name	Club	Status	Grade	PNUM	Pts	Plyd	Opps	Act	Plyd	Exp	Diff	Perf
2	Ferry, Edward	GM	-	1885	3912	1½	2	1591	1½	2	1.668	-0.168	1784
3	Dempsey, John	GMBD	-	1751	6685	1	2	1556	1	2	1.502	-0.502	1556
1	Nolan, Graeme A	SH	-	2086	7691	2	2	1747	2	2	1.752	0.248	2147
5	Kerridge, Simon	BD	-	1424	15294	2	2	1024	1	1	0.918	0.082	1424
4	Voghouei, Bahloul	GM	-	1626	18307	2	2	1306	2	2	1.716	0.284	1705