Results to 1/2/98
Rd1: Inverness 1½-6½ Cathcart; Edinburgh 4-4 Bon Accord*; Caley 3½-4½ Castlehill; Dundee & Victoria 7½-½ Bearsden; Crowwood 7½-½ Musselburgh; Ardrossan 4½-3½ Glasgow Polytechnic; Edinburgh West 6½-1½ Kilmarnock; Wandering Dragons 7-1 Oban. Rd2: Edinburgh West 6-2 Cathcart; Crowwood 6-2 Bon Accord; Wandering Dragons 5½-2½ Dundee & Victoria; Castlehill 5-3 Ardrossan. Rd3: Crowwood 6.5 - 1.5 Edinburgh West Wandering Dragons 6 - 2 Castlehill Final Crowwood 4.5 - 3.5 Wandering Dragons Releg R1: Glasgow Polytechnic 5-3 Edinburgh; Inverness w/o Caley; Bearsden* 4-4 Kilmarnock; Oban 3.5-4.5 Musselburgh. Releg R2: Edinburgh 4½-3½ Kilmarnock
Rd1: Inverclyde Cent 4½-1½ Perth; Paisley YMCA 6-0 Deans White Knights; Prestwick 3½-2½ Phones; Kirkcaldy w/o Bothwell & Uddingston; Giffnock & Clarkston* 3-3 Stirling; Dunfermline* 3-3 Dumfries & dist. Rd2: Giffnock & Clarkston**3-3 Inverclyde Cent; Kirkcaldy 5-1 Civil Service; Dunfermline 3½-2½ Paisley YMCA; Grangemouth Jun 4-2 Prestwick.
Draw: Bothwell & Uddingston v Phones, winner v Stirling; Rd1: Dumfries & dist 4-2 Deans White Knights. winner v Perth
* Won on Board Count, ** Won on elimination Richardson/Spens Finals 1998 commentary
Richardson detailed results
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
13 Kilmarnock 10 Edinburgh W
1995 Galbraith David T 0 - 1 Arakhamia Ketevan (I 2435
1820 Malkin Kenneth 0 - 1 Grant Jonathan I M 2275
1815 Cameron Nicholas R G ½ - ½ Khan Kalimullah 2195
1820 Kleboe James P R 1 - 0 Roberts Paul E 2145
1810 Hamilton Douglas 0 - 1 Farrell Neil R 2130
1780 Parks Joe 0 - 1 Gillam Simon R 2100
1735 Docherty James 0 - 1 Buchanan Walter F 2085
1585 MacNicoll John D 0 - 1 MacInally Pat 2075
1½ - 6½
12 Inverness 6 Cathcart
2040 Parkin James M 0 - 1 MacKay Roddy M (IM) 2360
1900 MacKenzie Donald 0 - 1 Grant Alan G 2195
1870 Shaw Kevin F 1 - 0 Maxwell Alistair 2075
1775 Brown Ken A 0 - 1 Harkins Michael G 1885
1605 Chapman Brian P 0 - 1 Maguire Kevin 1835
0 Rough R ½ - ½ Dougan H Campbell 1760
1455 MacRobert George R 0 - 1 Beaton Stephen 1755
1340 Hunt Thomas W 0 - 1 Nielsen Jan H 1735
1½ - 6½
7 Crowwood 14 Musselburgh
2335 Mannion Stephen R (I 1 - 0 Paterson Graham 2145
2385 Bryson Douglas M (IM 1 - 0 Russell David 1855
2230 Norris Alan 1 - 0 Konarski Jannic 1875
2025 Henderson John B 1 - 0 Galbraith Joe 1815
2020 Gallagher Anthony 1 - 0 Soutar Gavin I 1795
2030 Nolan Graeme ½ - ½ Moretta Brian 1765
1990 MacGowan Paul J 1 - 0 Stevens Ian 1695
1965 Paul Rabindra 1 - 0 Barron Vince 1485
7½ - ½
3 Bon Accord 9 Edinburgh
2120 Berry Neil M ½ - ½ Slaven Vincent 2045
1950 Shepherd Mike 1 - 0 Rutherford Willie 1945
1910 Cavanagh Mike 1 - 0 Rattray Michael J 1840
1885 Holmes Hugh D 0 - 1 Kynoch Richard J P 1825
1825 Coffey Thomas ½ - ½ Rutherford Elaine 1770
1810 Donaghay Michael R 1 - 0 Morrison Lynne G P 1765
1775 Eltahir Amir 0 - 1 Marshall William A 1760
1775 Clifford John 0 - 1 Montgomery David C 1675
4 - 4
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
2 Bearsden 8 Dundee &V
2060 Webb Jeff R L 0 - 1 MacNab Colin A (GM) 2480
2005 Watt David A ½ - ½ Findlay David J 2215
1945 Reid Norman 0 - 1 Romilly Peter J 2105
1880 MacElroy David J 0 - 1 Spencer Edwin A 2050
1815 Borland Thomas E 0 - 1 Myers Geoffrey 1885
1415 Goodall Alistair 0 - 1 Justice John J 1800
1110 Mehta Martin 0 - 1 Fallone Mike 1785
1215 Reid David 0 - 1 Anderson James 1745
½ - 7½
4 Caley 5 Castlehill
1880 Walsh Philip F 0 - 1 Wilman Carey A 2000
1810 MacGovern Patrick 0 - 1 Clapham Robert E 1975
1750 King Graeme E 1 - 0 Mooney Graham 1825
1735 Birnie Alan J 1 - 0 MacNab Ian A 1740
1630 Clark Stephen L ½ - ½ Chalmers Paul A 1605
1595 Yates Robin D 1 - 0 Noble Ray 1515
1570 Loughran Robert 0 - 1 Chalmers Martin M 1515
1485 Gourlay Robert 0 - 1 Paulin Andrew 1375
3½ - 4½
11 Polytechnic 1 Ardrossan
2145 Swan Iain 0 - 1 Brown Steven A 1950
2140 Byrne David G 0 - 1 Kelly William L 1915
2085 Kirk Larry G 0 - 1 Robinson Stephen 1780
2065 Minnican Alan W ½ - ½ Brown Andrew G 1730
2030 Reid Neil 1 - 0 Plato A Graeme D 1715
1840 Khandaker Iman ½ - ½ Walsh Alan 1610
1810 Watt Paul ½ - ½ MacLaggan J Iain 1510
1675 Neilan John 1 - 0 MacLaughlin Robert 1170
3½ - 4½
10 Edinburgh W 6 Cathcart
2275 Grant Jonathan I M 1 - 0 Grant Alan G 2195
2130 Farrell Neil R 0 - 1 Maxwell Alistair 2075
2145 Roberts Paul E ½ - ½ Harkins Michael G 1885
2100 Gillam Simon R ½ - ½ Maguire Kevin 1835
2085 Buchanan Walter F 1 - 0 Dougan H Campbell 1760
2075 MacInally Pat 1 - 0 Tsang Sai Kong 1630
1985 MacNally Bruce 1 - 0 Hamilton James 1565
1750 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1 - 0 Tortorella Arnold 1320
6 - 2
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
3 Bon Accord 7 Crowwood
2120 Berry Neil M ½ - ½ Mannion Stephen R (I 2335
1950 Shepherd Mike 0 - 1 Bryson Douglas M (IM 2385
1885 Holmes Hugh D 0 - 1 Muir Andrew J (IM) 2220
1825 Coffey Thomas 0 - 1 Henderson John B 2025
1810 Donaghay Michael R 1 - 0 Nolan Graeme 2030
1790 Brennan J Ross ½ - ½ MacGowan Paul J 1990
1775 Clifford John 0 - 1 Gallagher Anthony 2020
1670 MacKay George 0 - 1 Doyle James 1975
2 - 6
8 Dundee &V 16 Wand Dragons
2480 MacNab Colin A (GM) 1 - 0 Orr Mark J L (IM) 2420
2215 Findlay David J 1 - 0 Kilgour David A 2270
2105 Romilly Peter J ½ - ½ Thomson Craig S M (F 2270
2050 Spencer Edwin A 0 - 1 Burnett Andrew B 2235
1800 Justice John J 0 - 1 Bathie Nicol A 2210
1785 Fallone Mike 0 - 1 Weng Annegret 2165
1785 DeJong Walter 0 - 1 Pimentil Stephen 2060
1745 Anderson James 0 - 1 Campbell Eoin S 1895
2½ - 5½
5 Castlehill 1 Ardrossan
2000 Wilman Carey A ½ - ½ Brown Steven A 1950
1975 Clapham Robert E 0 - 1 Kelly William L 1915
1910 Kleppang David L 1 - 0 Gee L Douglas 1830
1825 Mooney Graham 1 - 0 Robinson Stephen 1780
1740 MacNab Ian A 1 - 0 Brown Andrew G 1730
1665 Nicol Craig S ½ - ½ Plato A Graeme D 1715
1605 Chalmers Paul A 0 - 1 Walsh Alan 1610
1515 Chalmers Martin M 1 - 0 MacLaughlin Robert 1170
5 - 3
16 Wand Dragons 5 Castlehill
2420 Orr Mark J L (IM) ½ - ½ Wilman Carey A 2000
2270 Kilgour David A 1 - 0 Clapham Robert E 1975
2235 Burnett Andrew B ½ - ½ Kleppang David L 1910
2210 Bathie Nicol A ½ - ½ Mooney Graham 1825
2180 Pickles Stephen M 1 - 0 MacNab Ian A 1740
2165 Weng Annegret 1 - 0 Nicol Craig S 1665
2135 Bennett William 1 - 0 Chalmers Martin M 1515
2060 Pimentil Stephen ½ - ½ Paulin Andrew 1375
6 - 2
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
14 Musselburgh 15 Oban
2145 Paterson Graham ½ - ½ Lennox C Jonathan 2120
1875 Konarski Jannic 0 - 1 Harrold Bruce T 1860
1855 Russell David ½ - ½ Abbott John A 1810
1815 Galbraith Joe ½ - ½ Campbell Duncan A F 1765
1795 Soutar Gavin I ½ - ½ Gillespie Dave L 1750
1765 Moretta Brian 1 - 0 Campbell Alistair W 1715
1695 Stevens Ian 1 - 0 Fisher James R 1710
1485 Barron Vince ½ - ½ Murphy Alan M 1555
4½ - 3½
2 Bearsden 13 Kilmarnock
2060 Webb Jeff R L 1 - 0 Galbraith David T 1995
1945 Reid Norman 0 - 1 Malkin Kenneth 1820
1880 MacElroy David J 1 - 0 Kleboe James P R 1820
1815 Borland Thomas E 0 - 1 Hamilton Douglas 1810
1655 Burt J Mel 1 - 0 Parks Joe 1780
1530 Dyer Ian 1 - 0 Docherty James 1735
1415 Goodall Alistair 0 - 1 MacMillan Ian 1545
1110 Mehta Martin 0 - 1 Ritchie Anthony 1445
4 - 4
15 Oban 4 Caley
2120 Lennox C Jonathan 1 - 0 Walsh Philip F 1880
1860 Harrold Bruce T 1 - 0 MacGovern Patrick 1810
1810 Abbott John A 0 - 1 Barrett Tommy 1785
1750 Gillespie Dave L 1 - 0 King Graeme E 1750
1715 Campbell Alistair W 1 - 0 Thomson Andrew 1710
1710 Fisher James R ½ - ½ Clark Stephen L 1630
1710 Gannon Martin 0 - 1 Yates Robin D 1595
1555 Murphy Alan M 1 - 0 Loughran Robert 1570
5½ - 2½
9 Edinburgh 13 Kilmarnock
2075 Weston Richard W 1 - 0 Rattray Gordon 2065
2045 Slaven Vincent 0 - 1 Galbraith David T 1995
1965 Eynon David ½ - ½ Cameron Nicholas R G 1815
1945 Rutherford Willie 1 - 0 Hamilton Douglas 1810
1825 Kynoch Richard J P 0 - 1 Malkin Kenneth 1820
1770 Rutherford Elaine ½ - ½ Kleboe James P R 1820
1800 Taylor Ewan ½ - ½ Parks Joe 1780
1760 Marshall William A 1 - 0 Docherty James 1735
4½ - 3½
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
10 Edinburgh W 7 Crowwood
2275 Grant Jonathan I M 0 - 1 Mannion Stephen R (I 2335
2130 Farrell Neil R ½ - ½ Bryson Douglas M (IM 2385
2100 Gillam Simon R 0 - 1 Muir Andrew J (IM) 2220
2085 Buchanan Walter F ½ - ½ Norris Alan 2230
2075 MacInally Pat ½ - ½ Nolan Graeme 2030
1985 MacNally Bruce 0 - 1 Henderson John B 2025
1750 Walkingshaw Andrew D 0 - 1 MacGowan Paul J 1990
1575 Deas William B 0 - 1 Gallagher Anthony 2020
1½ - 6½
11 Polytechnic 9 Edinburgh
2375 Shaw John K (FM) 1 - 0 Eynon David 1965
2110 Beaton Ken S 0 - 1 Rutherford Willie 1945
2065 Minnican Alan W ½ - ½ Rattray Michael J 1840
2030 Reid Neil ½ - ½ Kynoch Richard J P 1825
1840 Khandaker Iman 1 - 0 Rutherford Elaine 1770
1810 Watt Paul 1 - 0 Marshall William A 1760
1790 Hutchings David C 0 - 1 Aitchison A Keith 1695
Not Given - Not Given Not Played
4 - 3
15 Oban 16 Wand Dragons
2120 Lennox C Jonathan 0 - 1 Orr Mark J L (IM) 2420
1765 Campbell Duncan A F 0 - 1 Burnett Andrew B 2235
1555 Murphy Alan M 0 - 1 Pickles Stephen M 2180
1355 Ogden John 0 - 1 Vangelov Peter 1810
1750 Gillespie Dave L 0 - 1 Campbell Eoin S 1895
1715 Campbell Alistair W 0 - 1 Heron Donald 1880
1810 Abbott John A ½ - ½ Pimentil Stephen 2060
1710 Fisher James R ½ - ½ Tate Alan 1740
1 - 7
7 Crowwood 16 Wand Dragons
2335 Mannion Stephen R (I ½ - ½ Orr Mark J L (IM) 2420
2385 Bryson Douglas M (IM 1 - 0 Kilgour David A 2270
2230 Norris Alan 0 - 1 Burnett Andrew B 2235
2220 Muir Andrew J (IM) 1 - 0 Bathie Nicol A 2210
2030 Nolan Graeme ½ - ½ Pickles Stephen M 2180
2025 Henderson John B ½ - ½ Weng Annegret 2165
2020 Gallagher Anthony 0 - 1 Bennett William 2135
1860 Hopper Paul D 1 - 0 Campbell Eoin S 1895
4½ - 3½
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
Table Order = M pts
----------Boards (8 per Match)--------
----Matches---- ---Played--- --Defaults-- -Score-
Pos Team P W L D Pts W L D W L D Bds %
1 7 Crowwood 4 4 0 0 8 20 3 9 0 0 0 24½ 77
2 16 Wand Dragons 4 3 1 0 6 17 5 10 0 0 0 22 69
3 10 Edinburgh W 3 2 1 0 4 11 7 6 0 0 0 14 58
4 5 Castlehill 3 2 1 0 4 8 9 7 0 0 0 11½ 48
5 9 Edinburgh 3 1 1 1 3 8 8 7 0 1 0 11½ 48
6 8 Dundee &V 2 1 1 0 2 9 5 2 0 0 0 10 63
7 6 Cathcart 2 1 1 0 2 7 6 3 0 0 0 8½ 53
8 11 Polytechnic 2 1 1 0 2 5 5 5 0 1 0 7½ 47
9 1 Ardrossan 2 1 1 0 2 5 6 5 0 0 0 7½ 47
10 15 Oban 3 1 2 0 2 6 10 8 0 0 0 10 42
11 14 Musselburgh 2 1 1 0 2 2 8 6 0 0 0 5 31
12 13 Kilmarnock 3 0 2 1 1 7 13 4 0 0 0 9 38
13 3 Bon Accord 2 0 1 1 1 4 8 4 0 0 0 6 38
14 2 Bearsden 2 0 1 1 1 4 11 1 0 0 0 4½ 28
15 4 Caley 2 0 2 0 0 5 9 2 0 0 0 6 38
16 12 Inverness 1 0 1 0 0 1 6 1 0 0 0 1½ 19
-- -- -- -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ----
Tots for x-check 40 18 18 4 40 119 119 80 0 2 0 159
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
Match Cross Table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Pld Pts
1 Ardrossan x 3 4½ 16 7½
2 Bearsden x ½ 4 16 4½
3 Bon Accord x 2 4 16 6
4 Caley x 3½ 2½ 16 6
5 Castlehill 5 4½ x 2 24 11½
6 Cathcart x 2 6½ 16 8½
7 Crowwood 6 x 6½ 7½ 4½ 32 24½
8 Dundee &V 7½ x 2½ 16 10
9 Edinburgh 4 x 3 4½ 24 11½
10 Edinburgh W 6 1½ x 6½ 24 14
11 Polytechnic 3½ 4 x 16 7½
12 Inverness 1½ x 8 1½
13 Kilmarnock 4 3½ 1½ x 24 9
14 Musselburgh ½ x 4½ 16 5
15 Oban 5½ 3½ x 1 24 10
16 Wand Dragons 6 3½ 5½ 7 x 32 22
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
*** Team 1 Ardrossan ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3319 Brown Steven A 1950 AR 2 1½
4555 Kelly William L 1915 AR 2 2
5828 Robinson Stephen 1780 AR 2 1
3293 Brown Andrew G 1730 J15 AR 2 ½
8948 Plato A Graeme D 1715 J17 LG 2 ½
6364 Walsh Alan 1610 AR 2 1½
5154 MacLaggan J Iain 1510 AR 1 ½
8904 MacLaughlin Robert 1170 AR 2 0
4041 Gee L Douglas 1830 ARIR 1 0
*** Team 2 Bearsden ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6425 Webb Jeff R L 2060 BD 2 1
6416 Watt David A 2005 BD 1 ½
5745 Reid Norman 1945 BD 2 0
5023 MacElroy David J 1880 BD 2 1
3238 Borland Thomas E 1815 BD 2 0
4115 Goodall Alistair 1415 BD 2 0
10029 Mehta Martin 1110 J15 BD 2 0
7907 Reid David 1215 J20 BD 1 0
3365 Burt J Mel 1655 BD 1 1
7957 Dyer Ian 1530 BDGU 1 1
*** Team 3 Bon Accord ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3187 Berry Neil M 2120 J20 BNAU 2 1
5969 Shepherd Mike 1950 BPBA 2 1
3468 Cavanagh Mike 1910 BA 1 1
4371 Holmes Hugh D 1885 BA 2 0
3548 Coffey Thomas 1825 RGHC 2 ½
3759 Donaghay Michael R 1810 BAHB 2 2
11475 Eltahir Amir 1775 NEW BAAT 1 0
3534 Clifford John 1775 ATBA 2 0
3276 Brennan J Ross 1790 ATBA 1 ½
4783 MacKay George 1670 RGEW 1 0
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
*** Team 4 Caley ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6369 Walsh Philip F 1880 CY 2 0
5063 MacGovern Patrick 1810 AR 2 0
4597 King Graeme E 1750 CY 2 1
3199 Birnie Alan J 1735 CY 1 1
3522 Clark Stephen L 1630 CY 2 1
6559 Yates Robin D 1595 CYGI 2 2
4725 Loughran Robert 1570 CY 2 0
7499 Gourlay Robert 1485 KI 1 0
3137 Barrett Tommy 1785 CY 1 1
6234 Thomson Andrew 1710 CY 1 0
*** Team 5 Castlehill ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6799 Wilman Carey A 2000 CH 3 2
3509 Clapham Robert E 1975 CH 3 1
7382 Mooney Graham 1825 CH 3 1½
5192 MacNab Ian A 1740 CH 3 1
3478 Chalmers Paul A 1605 CH 2 ½
8657 Noble Ray 1515 CH 1 0
3477 Chalmers Martin M 1515 CH 3 2
11841 Paulin Andrew 1375 J18 CH 2 1½
4612 Kleppang David L 1910 CH 2 1½
5485 Nicol Craig S 1665 CH 2 ½
*** Team 6 Cathcart ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5115 MacKay Roddy M (IM) 2360 CC 1 1
4162 Grant Alan G 2195 CC 2 1
4903 Maxwell Alistair 2075 CCCW 2 1
4264 Harkins Michael G 1885 CC 2 1½
8977 Maguire Kevin 1835 CC 2 1½
3780 Dougan H Campbell 1760 CCGI 2 ½
7825 Beaton Stephen 1755 CC 1 1
5487 Nielsen Jan H 1735 CC 1 1
8938 Tsang Sai Kong 1630 J20 CC 1 0
9182 Hamilton James 1565 CC 1 0
6288 Tortorella Arnold 1320 CCPO 1 0
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
*** Team 7 Crowwood ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4858 Mannion Stephen R (IM) 2335 CW 4 3
3332 Bryson Douglas M (IM) 2385 SHCW 4 3½
9315 Norris Alan 2230 CWAA 3 1½
4322 Henderson John B 2025 CW 4 3½
4019 Gallagher Anthony 2020 SHCW 4 3
7691 Nolan Graeme 2030 J19 SHCW 4 1½
5071 MacGowan Paul J 1990 CW 3 2½
10019 Paul Rabindra 1965 CW 1 1
5400 Muir Andrew J (IM) 2220 SHCW 3 3
3788 Doyle James 1975 SHCW 1 1
4381 Hopper Paul D 1860 J18 BASH 1 1
*** Team 8 Dundee &V ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5190 MacNab Colin A (GM) 2480 DV 2 2
3919 Findlay David J 2215 DV 2 1½
5843 Romilly Peter J 2105 DV 2 1½
6072 Spencer Edwin A 2050 DVCH 2 1
5448 Myers Geoffrey 1885 DV 1 1
4516 Justice John J 1800 DV 2 1
7588 Fallone Mike 1785 DV 2 1
3051 Anderson James 1745 DV 2 1
11855 DeJong Walter 1785 DV 1 0
*** Team 9 Edinburgh ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6006 Slaven Vincent 2045 EDDM 2 ½
5882 Rutherford Willie 1945 ED 3 2
7714 Rattray Michael J 1840 J19 ED 2 ½
4629 Kynoch Richard J P 1825 ED 3 1½
6744 Rutherford Elaine 1770 J14 ED 3 1
5377 Morrison Lynne G P 1765 EDEU 1 0
6804 Marshall William A 1760 ED 3 2
10572 Montgomery David C 1675 EDWD 1 1
3866 Eynon David 1965 J16 BNGH 2 ½
3020 Aitchison A Keith 1695 ED 1 1
6442 Weston Richard W 2075 J20 CHBN 1 1
9448 Taylor Ewan 1800 ED 1 ½
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
*** Team 10 Edinburgh W ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
11217 Arakhamia Ketevan (IM) 2435 EWCW 1 1
4168 Grant Jonathan I M 2275 EWSO 3 2
12513 Khan Kalimullah 2195 EWXK 1 ½
5797 Roberts Paul E 2145 EW 2 ½
3881 Farrell Neil R 2130 EW 3 1½
4077 Gillam Simon R 2100 EW 3 1½
3336 Buchanan Walter F 2085 EW 3 2½
9027 MacInally Pat 2075 ED 3 2½
5194 MacNally Bruce 1985 EWHC 2 1
7993 Walkingshaw Andrew D 1750 J17 EW 2 1
3705 Deas William B 1575 EW 1 0
*** Team 11 Polytechnic ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6171 Swan Iain 2145 PY 1 0
3374 Byrne David G 2140 PY 1 0
4607 Kirk Larry G 2085 PY 1 0
5288 Minnican Alan W 2065 PY 2 1
5747 Reid Neil 2030 PY 2 1½
10412 Khandaker Iman 1840 PY 2 1½
10035 Watt Paul 1810 J17 PY 2 1½
7830 Neilan John 1675 PY 1 1
5961 Shaw John K (FM) 2375 KMPY 1 1
3157 Beaton Ken S 2110 PY 1 0
4433 Hutchings David C 1790 PY 1 0
*** Team 12 Inverness ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
10085 Parkin James M 2040 J16 IV 1 0
4791 MacKenzie Donald 1900 IV 1 0
7760 Shaw Kevin F 1870 IV 1 1
3312 Brown Ken A 1775 IV 1 0
3485 Chapman Brian P 1605 IV 1 0
12928 Rough R 0 IV 1 ½
5224 MacRobert George R 1455 IV 1 0
4416 Hunt Thomas W 1340 IV 1 0
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
*** Team 13 Kilmarnock ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4014 Galbraith David T 1995 KMAR 3 1
7619 Malkin Kenneth 1820 KM 3 2
7194 Cameron Nicholas R G 1815 J18 KM 2 1
4611 Kleboe James P R 1820 KM 3 1½
4236 Hamilton Douglas 1810 KM 3 1
5575 Parks Joe 1780 KM 3 ½
3744 Docherty James 1735 KM 3 0
5209 MacNicoll John D 1585 KM 1 0
5186 MacMillan Ian 1545 KM 1 1
8939 Ritchie Anthony 1445 KM 1 1
5719 Rattray Gordon 2065 KM 1 0
*** Team 14 Musselburgh ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5585 Paterson Graham 2145 MUWD 2 ½
5870 Russell David 1855 BAMU 2 ½
4621 Konarski Jannic 1875 WD 2 0
4015 Galbraith Joe 1815 MUBB 2 ½
6065 Soutar Gavin I 1795 MUWD 2 ½
5349 Moretta Brian 1765 MU 2 1½
8679 Stevens Ian 1695 J18 PLMU 2 1
7839 Barron Vince 1485 MU 2 ½
*** Team 15 Oban ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
8638 Lennox C Jonathan 2120 TBOB 3 1½
4277 Harrold Bruce T 1860 OB 2 2
3001 Abbott John A 1810 OBLS 3 1
3411 Campbell Duncan A F 1765 OB 2 ½
4079 Gillespie Dave L 1750 CWOB 3 1½
3403 Campbell Alistair W I 1715 OBEW 3 1
3934 Fisher James R 1710 CW 3 1
5423 Murphy Alan M 1555 OB 3 1½
4024 Gannon Martin 1710 LCOB 1 0
5546 Ogden John 1355 OB 1 0
Season 1998 Richardson Cup 97-98
*** Team 16 Wand Dragons ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5555 Orr Mark J L (IM) 2420 WD 4 2
4590 Kilgour David A 2270 LSGS 3 1
6238 Thomson Craig S M (FM) 2270 WD 1 ½
3349 Burnett Andrew B 2235 KCGN 4 3½
3145 Bathie Nicol A 2210 WDDV 3 1½
12511 Weng Annegret 2165 WDXK 3 2½
7705 Pimentil Stephen 2060 WD 3 2
3415 Campbell Eoin S 1895 WD 3 2
10143 Pickles Stephen M 2180 EU 3 2½
7576 Vangelov Peter 1810 ED 1 1
4339 Heron Donald 1880 WDED 1 1
6191 Tate Alan 1740 J18 WDBN 1 ½
7570 Bennett William 2135 EDWD 2 2
Spens detailed results
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
6 Giffnock &C 14 Stirling
1815 Leithead William E ½ - ½ Cowe Iain 1740
1705 Graham Joe 0 - 1 Pitson Anthony E 1695
1700 Hamilton Colin J 1 - 0 Hunter William 1690
1685 Farrell Vincent 1 - 0 Togneri Robert G 1575
1540 Fisher Richard T ½ - ½ Thomson Alex D C 1510
1515 MacCall John 0 - 1 MacAteer John 1390
3 - 3
8 Inverclyde C 11 Perth
2130 Montgomery Jim 1 - 0 Roth Michael J 1825
2070 MacDonald Kevin 1 - 0 Hall David G 1820
1875 Hilton Steve H 1 - 0 Falconer James N 1740
1700 Doherty Stephen 0 - 1 Hall Adam W 1525
1695 Collins Sam ½ - ½ Mitchell Ian W S 1440
1585 MacGranaghan James 1 - 0 Hall Colin P 1365
4½ - 1½
3 Dumfries &d 4 Dunfermline
1920 Green Mike L 0 - 1 Robertson Ian C 2115
1885 Muir Phil S ½ - ½ Forbes Andrew W 1715
1870 Brown David E ½ - ½ Brisbane W Stewart 1715
1640 Cunningham Stephen 1 - 0 Washington Ian 1280
1550 Carruthers John 0 - 1 Webb George 1280
1470 Maxwell Les 1 - 0 Campbell Tim 1135
3 - 3
10 Paisley YMCA 2 Deans WK
2120 Jamieson Peter M (FM 1 - 0 Murray Stephen 1685
2010 Cochrane Richard 1 - 0 Petch Rab 1500
1930 Matheis Thomas 1 - 0 Miller Ross 1435
1670 Nisbet Alex 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
1595 MacCormack Derek 1 - 0 Matthews Colin 1085
1530 Rooney Michael (Snr) 1 - 0 Maybon D 0
6 - 0
13 Prestwick 12 Phones
1810 Weir Gary 1 - 0 Macdonald Stuart 2040
1805 Fraser Iain R 1 - 0 Dickson Robert 1895
1675 Weir J Len 0 - 1 Brady Stuart 1915
1670 Malcolm Duncan 1 - 0 Strathern Kevin M 1805
1665 MacPheator Gary 0 - 1 MacIntyre John W 1805
1610 MacCurley Arthur ½ - ½ Carlin Joe 1750
3½ - 2½
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
8 Inverclyde C 6 Giffnock &C
2130 Montgomery Jim 1 - 0 Graham Joe 1705
1875 Hilton Steve H 0 - 1 Hamilton Colin J 1700
1895 Moffat Leonie ½ - ½ Fisher Richard T 1540
1700 Doherty Stephen ½ - ½ MacCall John 1515
1560 Gjaltema Simon D 0 - 1 Bonnyman Gordon J 1355
1490 Smith Andy 1 - 0 Wood Evan A 1345
3 - 3
9 Kirkcaldy 5 Civil Servic
2065 Pyrich George D ½ - ½ Kellett Simon C 1890
2035 Fyfe Graeme S S 1 - 0 Greensmith David 1815
1805 Thomson Thomas 1 - 0 Austin Rudolf J 1665
1715 Saxton Gavin 1 - 0 MacDonald Gordon J 1625
1680 Pearson Walter J 1 - 0 Brown Gerry 1545
1500 Donohoe Stephen ½ - ½ Anderson George C 1540
5 - 1
4 Dunfermline 10 Paisley YMCA
2115 Robertson Ian C ½ - ½ Umesh Santosh 2135
1875 O'Neil Jim ½ - ½ Matheis Thomas 1930
1845 Sneddon Ian D 1 - 0 Roy Michael 1700
1715 Ossowski Francis G 0 - 1 Kafka Graeme 1640
1715 Brisbane W Stewart 1 - 0 MacCormack Derek 1595
1570 MacArthur John M ½ - ½ Rooney Michael (Snr) 1530
3½ - 2½
7 Grangemouth 13 Prestwick
2040 MacLay John W ½ - ½ Weir Gary 1810
1985 Mather Walter ½ - ½ Fraser Iain R 1805
1915 Will Douglas 1 - 0 Weir J Len 1675
1840 Feighan Kevin 1 - 0 Malcolm Duncan 1670
1610 Watson James Philip 1 - 0 MacPheator Gary 1665
1605 Smith John 0 - 1 MacCurley Arthur 1610
4 - 2
6 Giffnock &C 9 Kirkcaldy
1815 Leithead William E 0 - 1 Fyfe Graeme S S 2035
1705 Graham Joe 0 - 1 Thomson Thomas 1805
1700 Hamilton Colin J 1 - 0 Saxton Gavin 1715
1540 Fisher Richard T 0 - 1 Pearson Walter J 1680
1515 MacCall John ½ - ½ Donohoe Stephen 1500
1355 Bonnyman Gordon J 1 - 0 MacRoberts Douglas G 1435
2½ - 3½
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
4 Dunfermline 7 Grangemouth
2115 Robertson Ian C 0 - 1 Gilfillan Andrew W 2010
1875 O'Neil Jim ½ - ½ MacLay John W 2040
1845 Sneddon Ian D ½ - ½ Mather Walter 1985
1715 Ossowski Francis G 0 - 1 Will Douglas 1915
1715 Brisbane W Stewart 1 - 0 Mason Ian C 1890
1715 Forbes Andrew W 1 - 0 Wilson Donald M 1685
3 - 3
1 Bothwell 12 Phones
1715 Findlay James 0 - 1 Macdonald Stuart 2040
1640 Rennie Andrew ½ - ½ Dickson Robert 1895
1620 Mulholland Arthur L 0 - 1 Brady Stuart 1915
1620 Miller Craig 0 - 1 Strathern Kevin M 1805
1580 Musgrave Richard 0 - 1 MacIntyre John W 1805
1310 Magowan Brian 0 - 1 Carlin Joe 1750
½ - 5½
2 Deans WK 3 Dumfries &d
1685 Murray Stephen 0 - 1 Green Mike L 1920
1500 Petch Rab 1 - 0 Brown David E 1870
1435 Miller Ross 0 - 1 MacIlhinney Eric 1610
1425 Thomson George 0 - 1 Carruthers John 1550
1260 Tonner Hugh 0 - 1 Maxwell Les 1470
1210 Taylor Dave 1 - 0 Thomson Colin 1455
2 - 4
12 Phones 14 Stirling
2040 Macdonald Stuart 0 - 1 Fraser Scott 1840
1915 Brady Stuart 1 - 0 Smith Stephen H 1740
1805 Strathern Kevin M ½ - ½ Hewitt David A 1650
1805 MacIntyre John W 1 - 0 Platts William G C 1590
1750 Carlin Joe 1 - 0 Togneri Robert G 1575
1575 Paterson Colin C 0 - 1 Thomson Alex D C 1510
3½ - 2½
7 Grangemouth 9 Kirkcaldy
2040 MacLay John W 0 - 1 Pyrich George D 2065
1985 Mather Walter 0 - 1 Fyfe Graeme S S 2035
1915 Will Douglas ½ - ½ Thomson Thomas 1805
1685 Wilson Donald M 0 - 1 Saxton Gavin 1715
1610 Watson James Philip 0 - 1 Pearson Walter J 1680
1435 Gray B William 0 - 1 Donohoe Stephen 1500
½ - 5½
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
3 Dumfries &d 12 Phones
1920 Green Mike L ½ - ½ Macdonald Stuart 2040
1885 Muir Phil S 0 - 1 Brady Stuart 1915
1870 Brown David E ½ - ½ Dickson Robert 1895
1610 MacIlhinney Eric 0 - 1 Strathern Kevin M 1805
1550 Carruthers John 0 - 1 Carlin Joe 1750
Not Given - Not Given Not Played
1 - 4
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
Table Order = M pts
----------Boards (6 per Match)--------
----Matches---- ---Played--- --Defaults-- -Score-
Pos Team P W L D Pts W L D W L D Bds %
1 9 Kirkcaldy 3 3 0 0 6 12 2 4 0 0 0 14 78
2 12 Phones 4 3 1 0 6 13 5 5 0 1 0 15½ 65
3 4 Dunfermline 3 1 0 2 4 6 5 7 0 0 0 9½ 53
4 8 Inverclyde C 2 1 0 1 3 6 3 3 0 0 0 7½ 63
5 3 Dumfries &d 3 1 1 1 3 6 7 4 0 1 0 8 44
6 7 Grangemouth 3 1 1 1 3 5 8 5 0 0 0 7½ 42
7 10 Paisley YMCA 2 1 1 0 2 7 2 3 0 0 0 8½ 71
8 6 Giffnock &C 3 0 1 2 2 6 7 5 0 0 0 8½ 47
9 13 Prestwick 2 1 1 0 2 4 5 3 0 0 0 5½ 46
10 14 Stirling 2 0 1 1 1 4 5 3 0 0 0 5½ 46
11 11 Perth 1 0 1 0 0 1 4 1 0 0 0 1½ 25
12 5 Civil Servic 1 0 1 0 0 0 4 2 0 0 0 1 17
13 2 Deans WK 2 0 2 0 0 2 10 0 0 0 0 2 17
14 1 Bothwell 1 0 1 0 0 0 5 1 0 0 0 ½ 8
-- -- -- -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ----
Tots for x-check 32 12 12 8 32 72 72 46 0 2 0 95
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
Match Cross Table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Pld Pts
1 Bothwell x ½ 6 ½
2 Deans WK x 2 0 12 2
3 Dumfries &d 4 x 3 1 18 8
4 Dunfermline 3 x 3 3½ 18 9½
5 Civil Servic x 1 6 1
6 Giffnock &C x 3 2½ 3 18 8½
7 Grangemouth 3 x ½ 4 18 7½
8 Inverclyde C 3 x 4½ 12 7½
9 Kirkcaldy 5 3½ 5½ x 18 14
10 Paisley YMCA 6 2½ x 12 8½
11 Perth 1½ x 6 1½
12 Phones 5½ 4 x 2½ 3½ 24 15½
13 Prestwick 2 3½ x 12 5½
14 Stirling 3 2½ x 12 5½
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
*** Team 1 Bothwell ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6698 Findlay James 1715 UD 1 0
5758 Rennie Andrew 1640 UDCC 1 ½
5404 Mulholland Arthur L 1620 UD 1 0
9045 Miller Craig 1620 UD 1 0
5446 Musgrave Richard 1580 UD 1 0
4829 Magowan Brian 1310 UD 1 0
*** Team 2 Deans WK ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
12158 Murray Stephen 1685 NEW DSLV 2 0
5621 Petch Rab 1500 LV 2 1
10513 Miller Ross 1435 DSLV 2 0
11834 Wright Andrew 1285 NEW LV 1 0
11594 Matthews Colin 1085 DS 1 0
12929 Maybon D 0 DS 1 0
10598 Thomson George 1425 LV 1 0
11593 Tonner Hugh 1260 DS 1 0
10177 Taylor Dave 1210 DS 1 1
*** Team 3 Dumfries &d ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4186 Green Mike L 1920 DF 3 1½
5402 Muir Phil S 1885 DF 2 ½
9157 Brown David E 1870 DTKB 3 1
12222 Cunningham Stephen 1640 NEW DF 1 1
7542 Carruthers John 1550 DF 3 1
7551 Maxwell Les 1470 DF 2 2
9154 MacIlhinney Eric 1610 DF 2 1
7556 Thomson Colin 1455 DF 1 0
*** Team 4 Dunfermline ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5811 Robertson Ian C 2115 DLWD 3 1½
3956 Forbes Andrew W 1715 DL 2 1½
3281 Brisbane W Stewart 1715 DLCN 3 2½
10183 Washington Ian 1280 COKR 1 0
9323 Webb George 1280 DL 1 1
12365 Campbell Tim 1135 NEW DL 1 0
5536 O'Neil Jim 1875 DLWD 2 1
6061 Sneddon Ian D 1845 DL 2 1½
5557 Ossowski Francis G 1715 DL 2 0
4749 MacArthur John M 1570 DL 1 ½
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
*** Team 5 Civil Servic ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4539 Kellett Simon C 1890 CSHC 1 ½
7914 Greensmith David 1815 CS 1 0
3084 Austin Rudolf J 1665 EDCS 1 0
4765 MacDonald Gordon J 1625 CS 1 0
7921 Brown Gerry 1545 CS 1 0
3046 Anderson George C 1540 CS 1 ½
*** Team 6 Giffnock &C ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4683 Leithead William E 1815 GI 2 ½
7826 Graham Joe 1705 GI 3 0
4235 Hamilton Colin J 1700 GI 3 3
9931 Farrell Vincent 1685 J16 GINI 1 1
3936 Fisher Richard T 1540 GI 3 1
4946 MacCall John 1515 GICC 3 1
3234 Bonnyman Gordon J 1355 GI 2 2
11476 Wood Evan A 1345 J16 GI 1 0
*** Team 7 Grangemouth ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5168 MacLay John W 2040 GRWD 3 1
4893 Mather Walter 1985 DLGR 3 1
6473 Will Douglas 1915 GRWD 3 2½
3887 Feighan Kevin 1840 GRWD 1 1
6399 Watson James Philip 1610 GR 2 1
8494 Smith John 1605 GR 1 0
4075 Gilfillan Andrew W 2010 GRHC 1 1
4888 Mason Ian C 1890 GR 1 0
6501 Wilson Donald M 1685 GR 2 0
9179 Gray B William 1435 GRWD 1 0
*** Team 8 Inverclyde C ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5329 Montgomery Jim 2130 IC 2 2
5016 MacDonald Kevin 2070 IC 1 1
4357 Hilton Steve H 1875 PAPW 2 1
3754 Doherty Stephen 1700 ICPG 2 ½
3560 Collins Sam 1695 GMAY 1 ½
5073 MacGranaghan James 1585 IC 1 1
5313 Moffat Leonie 1895 PYIC 1 ½
4095 Gjaltema Simon D 1560 IC 1 0
6016 Smith Andy 1490 IC 1 1
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
*** Team 9 Kirkcaldy ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5692 Pyrich George D 2065 KCGN 2 1½
4008 Fyfe Graeme S S 2035 KC 3 3
6257 Thomson Thomas 1805 KC 3 2½
8807 Saxton Gavin 1715 KC 3 2
5607 Pearson Walter J 1680 KCGN 3 3
3772 Donohoe Stephen 1500 KCGN 3 2
8824 MacRoberts Douglas G 1435 KC 1 0
*** Team 10 Paisley YMCA ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4478 Jamieson Peter M (FM) 2120 PA 1 1
3543 Cochrane Richard 2010 PACW 1 1
4892 Matheis Thomas 1930 PA 2 1½
5489 Nisbet Alex 1670 PADA 1 1
8860 MacCormack Derek 1595 J15 PA 2 1
11986 Rooney Michael (Snr) 1530 NEW PACW 2 1½
6315 Umesh Santosh 2135 J20 PA 1 ½
7867 Roy Michael 1700 J19 PA 1 0
4517 Kafka Graeme 1640 J15 LGPA 1 1
*** Team 11 Perth ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
9972 Roth Michael J 1825 PRCH 1 0
4230 Hall David G 1820 PR 1 0
3870 Falconer James N 1740 PR 1 0
6653 Hall Adam W 1525 J14 PRCF 1 1
5302 Mitchell Ian W S 1440 PR 1 ½
8712 Hall Colin P 1365 J10 PRCF 1 0
*** Team 12 Phones ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
4818 Macdonald Stuart 2040 PO 4 1½
3731 Dickson Robert 1895 KRPO 3 1
3264 Brady Stuart 1915 PO 4 4
6645 Strathern Kevin M 1805 KRPO 4 2½
5102 MacIntyre John W 1805 PO 3 3
3440 Carlin Joe 1750 PO 4 3½
5582 Paterson Colin C 1575 POKN 1 0
Season 1998 Spens Cup 1997-98
*** Team 13 Prestwick ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6434 Weir Gary 1810 TR 2 1½
3983 Fraser Iain R 1805 PWTR 2 1½
6435 Weir J Len 1675 TR 2 0
4847 Malcolm Duncan 1670 TR 2 1
5217 MacPheator Gary 1665 AYPW 2 0
4998 MacCurley Arthur 1610 PW 2 1½
*** Team 14 Stirling ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
3616 Cowe Iain 1740 ST 1 ½
5644 Pitson Anthony E 1695 STDB 1 1
12220 Hunter William 1690 ST 1 0
6276 Togneri Robert G 1575 ST 2 0
6236 Thomson Alex D C 1510 ST 2 1½
9353 MacAteer John 1390 ST 1 1
7776 Fraser Scott 1840 J16 ST 1 1
6052 Smith Stephen H 1740 STCW 1 0
8570 Hewitt David A 1650 ST 1 ½
5650 Platts William G C 1590 STDB 1 0